Revolution 250 Podcast
Revolution 250 Podcast
Manufacturing Independence with Robert Smith
Manufacturing Independence: Forging a Nation in the Crucible of War
What did it really take to turn rebellion into a revolution—and ideals into a functioning nation? In this episode of the Revolution 250 Podcast, host Professor Robert Allison welcomes Professor Robert Smith of the Valley Forge Military College, author of Manufacturing Independence: Industrial Innovation in the American Revolution, for a sweeping conversation about the workshops, foundries, supply lines, and human ingenuity that powered the American cause.
Smith peels back the romantic veneer of the Revolution to reveal a world of iron, timber, powder, and persistence. From cannon cast in makeshift furnaces to uniforms stitched by candlelight, listeners discover how farmers, artisans, merchants, and soldiers became the hidden engine of independence. Together, Allison and Smith explore how local industry, wartime logistics, and civilian resilience shaped strategy on the battlefield and survival on the home front.
This episode invites you into the noisy, smoky, and determined world behind the musket’s flash—where a nation was not only declared, but made. Whether you’re a history devotee or a curious first-time listener, Manufacturing Independence offers a fresh lens on how Americans forged freedom with their hands as much as with their words.
https://www.westholmepublishing.com/book/manufacturing-independence-robert-f-smith/
WEBVTT
00:00:01.459 --> 00:00:01.820
Hello.
00:00:01.899 --> 00:00:02.701
Hello, everyone.
00:00:03.080 --> 00:00:04.642
Welcome to the Revolution Two Fifty
00:00:04.682 --> 00:00:05.222
podcast.
00:00:05.243 --> 00:00:06.022
I'm Bob Allison.
00:00:06.083 --> 00:00:07.985
I chair the Rev Two Fifty Advisory Group
00:00:08.085 --> 00:00:09.885
and also teach history at Suffolk
00:00:09.965 --> 00:00:10.686
University.
00:00:11.106 --> 00:00:12.907
And our guest today is Robert Smith.
00:00:12.987 --> 00:00:15.769
And Robert Smith is the provost at Valley
00:00:15.789 --> 00:00:17.791
Forge College in Valley Forge,
00:00:17.830 --> 00:00:18.472
Pennsylvania.
00:00:19.172 --> 00:00:20.573
And we are going to be talking about
00:00:20.593 --> 00:00:23.234
his great book Manufacturing Independence
00:00:23.274 --> 00:00:25.477
Industrial Innovation in the American
00:00:25.556 --> 00:00:26.176
Revolution.
00:00:26.536 --> 00:00:26.998
And by the way,
00:00:27.018 --> 00:00:28.678
our podcast today is sponsored by the
00:00:28.719 --> 00:00:30.219
Richard Lounsbury Foundation.
00:00:30.600 --> 00:00:31.800
So thank you so much for joining us,
00:00:31.841 --> 00:00:32.100
Bob.
00:00:33.182 --> 00:00:33.963
It's good to be here.
00:00:34.122 --> 00:00:35.503
I'm excited to have this conversation.
00:00:37.365 --> 00:00:39.368
So this is one of those stories that
00:00:39.408 --> 00:00:41.529
we all should know better.
00:00:41.729 --> 00:00:43.750
And it's really an essential one to the
00:00:43.771 --> 00:00:44.851
story of the Revolution,
00:00:44.911 --> 00:00:47.073
how Americans went from being woefully
00:00:47.094 --> 00:00:50.576
unprepared for the war to actually being
00:00:50.616 --> 00:00:53.359
able to manufacture arms, munitions,
00:00:53.380 --> 00:00:55.040
the other things they needed to win the
00:00:55.060 --> 00:00:55.381
war.
00:00:55.521 --> 00:00:57.682
And you've told the story very well in
00:00:57.703 --> 00:00:58.143
this book.
00:00:59.274 --> 00:00:59.896
Thank you very much.
00:00:59.936 --> 00:01:00.595
I appreciate that.
00:01:00.957 --> 00:01:04.980
Yeah, I wish more people knew about it.
00:01:05.281 --> 00:01:08.864
I wish there was a greater respect for
00:01:09.444 --> 00:01:10.406
what the Americans were able to
00:01:10.426 --> 00:01:10.986
accomplish.
00:01:11.746 --> 00:01:14.329
I think that even two hundred and fifty
00:01:14.370 --> 00:01:14.930
years later,
00:01:14.990 --> 00:01:18.093
we still take it as as a miracle,
00:01:18.153 --> 00:01:19.795
as some kind of miracle.
00:01:20.676 --> 00:01:21.575
really lucky break.
00:01:23.296 --> 00:01:25.037
But the Americans have a lot of skill.
00:01:25.197 --> 00:01:28.638
They had a lot of resources available to
00:01:28.679 --> 00:01:30.899
them that they had to put into operation.
00:01:31.019 --> 00:01:31.719
And they did.
00:01:32.640 --> 00:01:32.900
Of course,
00:01:32.920 --> 00:01:34.781
it's not to the level that we get
00:01:34.820 --> 00:01:37.260
to later when we're an established nation.
00:01:37.361 --> 00:01:41.582
But for a country that's a couple of
00:01:41.623 --> 00:01:43.003
months and a couple of years old,
00:01:43.442 --> 00:01:44.804
I think it's a pretty good deal.
00:01:46.103 --> 00:01:47.548
so can we talk a little bit about
00:01:47.929 --> 00:01:50.575
what they do what are the beginnings of
00:01:50.614 --> 00:01:53.962
this industrial process that happened with
00:01:54.082 --> 00:01:55.045
the beginning of the war
00:01:56.245 --> 00:01:56.566
Sure,
00:01:56.706 --> 00:02:00.250
and to discuss that before we get into
00:02:00.269 --> 00:02:00.469
that,
00:02:00.549 --> 00:02:02.492
we need to frame what we're talking about
00:02:02.572 --> 00:02:04.093
in terms of industrialization.
00:02:05.073 --> 00:02:05.655
Typically,
00:02:07.537 --> 00:02:11.080
we as historians of technology and
00:02:11.379 --> 00:02:12.480
American history generally,
00:02:12.580 --> 00:02:18.306
we look at machinery and machines as being
00:02:18.366 --> 00:02:19.987
the be all and end all of innovation.
00:02:21.128 --> 00:02:25.031
And so we still today look at Samuel
00:02:25.070 --> 00:02:27.372
Slater as being the beginning of the
00:02:27.391 --> 00:02:29.152
Industrial Revolution in the United States
00:02:29.212 --> 00:02:35.074
and his water-powered mill in Rhode
00:02:35.155 --> 00:02:35.414
Island.
00:02:37.395 --> 00:02:39.497
Industrial innovation was happening prior
00:02:39.518 --> 00:02:39.818
to that.
00:02:39.919 --> 00:02:43.141
Industrial innovation was really taking
00:02:43.201 --> 00:02:43.902
two paths.
00:02:44.182 --> 00:02:45.604
One was machine driven.
00:02:46.245 --> 00:02:48.146
The other was organization driven.
00:02:48.467 --> 00:02:49.427
And of course, then,
00:02:50.429 --> 00:02:52.010
two hundred years after this point,
00:02:52.050 --> 00:02:54.032
we'll get to Henry Ford,
00:02:54.052 --> 00:02:55.655
who puts both of those together.
00:02:57.317 --> 00:03:01.038
But for the seventeenth through the
00:03:01.079 --> 00:03:01.979
nineteenth century,
00:03:02.019 --> 00:03:04.620
there is this struggle for, well,
00:03:04.719 --> 00:03:07.461
how are we going to make things better?
00:03:08.062 --> 00:03:09.502
What does manufacturing look like?
00:03:09.581 --> 00:03:11.502
And one of the options is machines.
00:03:11.983 --> 00:03:13.383
The other is organization.
00:03:13.463 --> 00:03:15.564
How do we organize workers?
00:03:15.965 --> 00:03:17.205
How do we train workers?
00:03:18.086 --> 00:03:19.406
How do we make them more efficient?
00:03:20.167 --> 00:03:22.848
And what we see here at the beginning
00:03:22.888 --> 00:03:24.889
of the American Industrial Revolution,
00:03:24.908 --> 00:03:25.368
in my opinion,
00:03:26.429 --> 00:03:27.889
And what we definitely see in the American
00:03:27.909 --> 00:03:30.711
Revolution for this is taking these
00:03:30.752 --> 00:03:34.093
workers who have skills, which, as I said,
00:03:34.133 --> 00:03:35.534
we have these resources in the United
00:03:35.574 --> 00:03:35.854
States.
00:03:35.955 --> 00:03:38.836
One of them is people, our people.
00:03:39.456 --> 00:03:42.618
We have skilled craftsmen that can do lots
00:03:42.639 --> 00:03:43.400
of different things.
00:03:43.479 --> 00:03:45.540
They may not all be gun makers.
00:03:45.580 --> 00:03:47.521
They may not all be weapons manufacturers,
00:03:47.983 --> 00:03:49.282
but they have skills that are
00:03:49.323 --> 00:03:50.024
transferable.
00:03:50.503 --> 00:03:53.006
And so if we can organize them and
00:03:53.126 --> 00:03:54.806
we learn to do that from the British,
00:03:55.048 --> 00:03:56.748
we see the British do this at Woolwich
00:03:56.808 --> 00:03:58.469
Arsenal and some of their other
00:03:58.490 --> 00:04:00.391
manufacturing sites.
00:04:00.972 --> 00:04:02.293
We know that the French are doing it.
00:04:04.055 --> 00:04:06.216
And if we can do that same thing,
00:04:06.256 --> 00:04:10.098
then we can really make a lot of
00:04:10.139 --> 00:04:14.723
progress out of the small resources that
00:04:14.742 --> 00:04:15.683
we're able to mobilize.
00:04:18.266 --> 00:04:21.629
and so there is a push then to
00:04:21.749 --> 00:04:24.430
create arsenals and and we know about a
00:04:24.531 --> 00:04:26.192
number of them and you you were talking
00:04:26.232 --> 00:04:27.954
earlier about going to carlisle and then
00:04:27.994 --> 00:04:32.216
looking at other places so um was there
00:04:32.377 --> 00:04:34.538
already you said they're already skilled
00:04:34.619 --> 00:04:36.360
craftsmen able to do things so what is
00:04:36.379 --> 00:04:38.281
the organizational strategy they then
00:04:38.341 --> 00:04:40.543
adapt in order to bring all of this
00:04:40.584 --> 00:04:42.625
together to an end they hadn't been
00:04:42.685 --> 00:04:45.026
anticipating before that is making rifles
00:04:45.047 --> 00:04:46.988
cannon as well as uniforms and other
00:04:47.009 --> 00:04:47.249
things
00:04:47.990 --> 00:04:50.670
So the Continental Congress knows from,
00:04:50.990 --> 00:04:53.591
again, these are smart people, right?
00:04:53.612 --> 00:04:56.733
Our founding fathers aren't these country
00:04:56.752 --> 00:04:58.994
bumpkins that, again, we sometimes,
00:04:59.774 --> 00:05:03.096
the mythology says that these guys kind of
00:05:03.136 --> 00:05:04.375
come up with this stuff out of thin
00:05:04.456 --> 00:05:04.656
air.
00:05:04.716 --> 00:05:05.276
And they don't.
00:05:05.317 --> 00:05:06.216
They're well-read.
00:05:07.598 --> 00:05:08.937
They're sharing knowledge across the
00:05:08.978 --> 00:05:09.577
Atlantic Ocean.
00:05:11.738 --> 00:05:13.218
One of the things they understand is how
00:05:13.259 --> 00:05:14.519
the British are manufacturing.
00:05:15.019 --> 00:05:16.680
They know the British ordnance system,
00:05:18.160 --> 00:05:20.880
which is a system of contractors and
00:05:21.341 --> 00:05:22.800
government-run arsenals.
00:05:24.302 --> 00:05:27.322
And if you go to any talk about
00:05:28.262 --> 00:05:30.843
British weapons in the eighteenth century,
00:05:31.043 --> 00:05:32.483
we talk about their pistols,
00:05:32.524 --> 00:05:33.783
about Brown Bess,
00:05:34.403 --> 00:05:37.824
you hear about the manufacturing at the
00:05:37.865 --> 00:05:38.485
Tower of London.
00:05:39.084 --> 00:05:42.367
There's also one at Woolwich Arsenal down
00:05:42.387 --> 00:05:43.766
at River Thames from London.
00:05:44.827 --> 00:05:45.588
There's several others.
00:05:45.708 --> 00:05:48.930
The Navy has Portsmouth Dockyard.
00:05:51.230 --> 00:05:52.851
But they know that these are being
00:05:52.951 --> 00:05:57.954
organized around a military system where
00:05:57.973 --> 00:06:00.095
you have a military hierarchy that
00:06:00.634 --> 00:06:04.177
recruits skilled craftsmen and encourages
00:06:04.216 --> 00:06:05.338
them to work together.
00:06:05.838 --> 00:06:07.879
And so you use that hierarchy
00:06:09.197 --> 00:06:12.879
to make sure that your cadre of carpenters
00:06:12.999 --> 00:06:14.778
are working with your cadre of
00:06:15.199 --> 00:06:15.798
blacksmiths.
00:06:18.000 --> 00:06:19.639
In the case of the Woolwich Arsenal,
00:06:20.339 --> 00:06:23.901
you do end up with trained armorers,
00:06:25.940 --> 00:06:26.862
cannon craftsmen,
00:06:28.081 --> 00:06:29.422
and the United States is going to do
00:06:29.461 --> 00:06:30.161
the same thing.
00:06:30.622 --> 00:06:32.502
They recognize that they don't have
00:06:33.483 --> 00:06:35.425
uh trained armors they don't have a
00:06:35.906 --> 00:06:39.129
plethora uh one uh
00:06:40.230 --> 00:06:42.112
One author's research that I looked at
00:06:42.232 --> 00:06:44.434
said that the United States might have had
00:06:44.454 --> 00:06:50.497
about three hundred actual gunsmiths at
00:06:50.517 --> 00:06:51.838
the time of the American Revolution.
00:06:52.319 --> 00:06:53.519
And so if you can get a few
00:06:53.579 --> 00:06:56.141
of them and get them to train or
00:06:56.182 --> 00:06:58.043
get them to be finishers for these
00:06:58.083 --> 00:06:58.663
products,
00:06:59.384 --> 00:07:01.464
then you can mobilize these other
00:07:01.485 --> 00:07:02.005
craftsmen.
00:07:02.065 --> 00:07:05.387
So what the Congress does is creates a
00:07:05.447 --> 00:07:07.189
roadmap for this and then appoints a
00:07:07.228 --> 00:07:09.750
gentleman named Benjamin Flower.
00:07:11.011 --> 00:07:13.432
who's a Pennsylvania well he's from
00:07:13.492 --> 00:07:14.673
Maryland originally but he lives in
00:07:14.692 --> 00:07:18.874
Philadelphia he's a craftsman and he is
00:07:18.913 --> 00:07:21.454
the person that puts this into place and
00:07:21.555 --> 00:07:24.475
what he does is he builds a regiment
00:07:24.516 --> 00:07:27.877
of artillery artificers it's common and
00:07:27.918 --> 00:07:29.997
this regiment is divided up into companies
00:07:30.778 --> 00:07:32.658
and each company is
00:07:36.029 --> 00:07:38.831
for the most part, specialized.
00:07:38.911 --> 00:07:40.333
So you'll have a company of carpenters,
00:07:40.353 --> 00:07:41.874
you'll have a company of blacksmiths,
00:07:42.593 --> 00:07:46.596
and then they'll recruit a few specialties
00:07:46.637 --> 00:07:47.137
within that.
00:07:47.177 --> 00:07:50.540
So you have tinsmiths, you have armorers,
00:07:53.430 --> 00:07:55.011
that are sprinkled in with these different
00:07:55.031 --> 00:07:55.430
groups.
00:07:55.992 --> 00:07:57.413
And then what you'll do with the arsenals,
00:07:57.432 --> 00:07:58.372
what they'll do at Philadelphia,
00:07:58.392 --> 00:07:59.314
so there's three arsenals,
00:07:59.634 --> 00:08:00.795
one at Philadelphia, one at,
00:08:01.435 --> 00:08:02.735
three main arsenals, I should say,
00:08:02.956 --> 00:08:05.298
Philadelphia, Carlisle, Pennsylvania,
00:08:05.939 --> 00:08:07.360
and Springfield, Massachusetts.
00:08:07.879 --> 00:08:09.880
And what they'll do is they'll have these
00:08:09.920 --> 00:08:10.382
companies
00:08:11.925 --> 00:08:14.028
commanded by their commander.
00:08:14.889 --> 00:08:18.351
But then one of those commanders is also
00:08:19.512 --> 00:08:21.274
a master craftsman in their field.
00:08:21.774 --> 00:08:24.697
And so then within the physical structure
00:08:25.298 --> 00:08:28.540
of the arsenals, they'll be organized.
00:08:29.101 --> 00:08:31.663
And they're managed by this overlapping
00:08:31.983 --> 00:08:32.565
hierarchy.
00:08:33.186 --> 00:08:34.326
And so then what you see
00:08:36.831 --> 00:08:39.192
Springfield is the best example because
00:08:39.212 --> 00:08:41.192
it's designed to look like Woolwich
00:08:41.253 --> 00:08:41.614
Arsenal.
00:08:41.994 --> 00:08:46.054
This big square where the manufacturing
00:08:46.095 --> 00:08:46.575
buildings,
00:08:47.095 --> 00:08:49.875
and it only gets better over time at
00:08:49.936 --> 00:08:50.495
Springfield.
00:08:50.756 --> 00:08:51.756
They build it out better.
00:08:52.697 --> 00:08:55.317
But initially, around this open square,
00:08:55.357 --> 00:08:56.918
you have the military stores buildings.
00:08:58.899 --> 00:09:00.460
the manufacturers of,
00:09:02.220 --> 00:09:03.961
or you say the carpenters are making gun
00:09:04.020 --> 00:09:04.421
stocks,
00:09:04.461 --> 00:09:06.201
they're making wagons and wagon wheels.
00:09:06.721 --> 00:09:08.081
And then they'll pass that on to the
00:09:08.101 --> 00:09:12.182
blacksmiths who will make the furniture to
00:09:12.202 --> 00:09:14.982
put the muskets together and the pieces,
00:09:15.023 --> 00:09:17.604
the tires for the wagon wheels.
00:09:17.884 --> 00:09:19.705
And then they'll build out Carlisle the
00:09:19.745 --> 00:09:20.164
same way.
00:09:21.184 --> 00:09:22.606
so that the physical structure of the
00:09:22.647 --> 00:09:26.211
place matches how they're organizing the
00:09:26.270 --> 00:09:26.912
men themselves.
00:09:28.313 --> 00:09:28.573
Interesting.
00:09:28.594 --> 00:09:29.794
We're talking with Bob Smith,
00:09:29.955 --> 00:09:32.097
author of Manufacturing Independence,
00:09:32.138 --> 00:09:34.139
Industrial Innovation in the American
00:09:34.200 --> 00:09:34.780
Revolution.
00:09:36.231 --> 00:09:39.495
now these guys are they actually
00:09:39.916 --> 00:09:41.398
blacksmiths carpenters when they're
00:09:41.437 --> 00:09:43.038
recruited or is that something they're
00:09:43.320 --> 00:09:46.043
recruited and become blacksmiths gunsmiths
00:09:46.702 --> 00:09:48.044
no they are that's a great question they
00:09:48.225 --> 00:09:50.447
are um blacksmiths and carpenters and tin
00:09:50.466 --> 00:09:52.629
smiths when they're recruited and uh
00:09:52.769 --> 00:09:54.390
flower and his commanders
00:09:55.518 --> 00:09:56.097
his subordinates,
00:09:57.379 --> 00:10:01.120
purposefully advertise to bring in these
00:10:01.160 --> 00:10:01.902
types of workers.
00:10:02.081 --> 00:10:04.823
And this isn't really so different from
00:10:04.903 --> 00:10:08.605
what we'll see in the Civil War and
00:10:08.645 --> 00:10:10.206
in the First and Second World Wars,
00:10:11.388 --> 00:10:14.168
where skilled craftsmen are brought into
00:10:14.208 --> 00:10:16.571
the war for specific tasks.
00:10:18.578 --> 00:10:22.123
My grandfather struggled greatly with the
00:10:22.163 --> 00:10:26.288
fact that he was a machinist and he
00:10:26.347 --> 00:10:29.471
managed a machine shop making tank guns.
00:10:30.352 --> 00:10:34.057
All of his brothers-in-law went to fight
00:10:34.076 --> 00:10:36.458
the war and he's stuck here.
00:10:37.837 --> 00:10:38.578
in his own mind,
00:10:39.240 --> 00:10:41.402
but he's performing a task that other
00:10:41.422 --> 00:10:42.182
people couldn't do.
00:10:42.243 --> 00:10:43.783
And we know that's a huge story in
00:10:43.844 --> 00:10:44.424
World War II,
00:10:44.524 --> 00:10:50.510
where men with specific tasks stay in the
00:10:51.432 --> 00:10:52.592
home front.
00:10:52.633 --> 00:10:53.374
The same thing is happening in the
00:10:53.394 --> 00:10:54.114
American Revolution.
00:10:54.855 --> 00:10:57.157
Congress, the War Department,
00:10:58.398 --> 00:11:00.158
or the Board of War, I should say,
00:11:01.200 --> 00:11:02.360
don't really have a department yet.
00:11:03.120 --> 00:11:05.403
They recognize that we have these people.
00:11:06.202 --> 00:11:07.823
And they want to give to the war
00:11:07.884 --> 00:11:08.144
effort.
00:11:08.164 --> 00:11:11.027
And it's a waste to send them to
00:11:11.086 --> 00:11:13.788
the front lines when, of course,
00:11:13.808 --> 00:11:15.330
the way we're fighting at that time is
00:11:15.389 --> 00:11:17.230
very formulaic.
00:11:17.671 --> 00:11:18.292
Line your men up.
00:11:18.471 --> 00:11:19.373
You shoot.
00:11:19.972 --> 00:11:20.373
No, no, no.
00:11:20.413 --> 00:11:22.033
These people are too good to waste.
00:11:23.014 --> 00:11:27.597
you bring them in and they may not
00:11:27.658 --> 00:11:28.697
know.
00:11:28.719 --> 00:11:31.799
These blacksmiths may not know how to make
00:11:32.581 --> 00:11:33.400
the furniture,
00:11:33.561 --> 00:11:35.282
the small pieces that hold a weapon
00:11:35.302 --> 00:11:35.682
together.
00:11:35.702 --> 00:11:39.504
They may not know how to make bayonets
00:11:39.985 --> 00:11:42.267
or ramrods or things like that,
00:11:42.307 --> 00:11:44.368
but you can train them for those things
00:11:44.408 --> 00:11:46.489
because they have the innate skills to do
00:11:46.509 --> 00:11:46.749
that.
00:11:47.210 --> 00:11:47.610
Then of course,
00:11:47.649 --> 00:11:48.971
the more important part is
00:11:49.892 --> 00:11:51.272
You have a blacksmith that has his own
00:11:51.312 --> 00:11:51.792
shop.
00:11:52.532 --> 00:11:56.832
He's not necessarily working side by side
00:11:56.873 --> 00:11:58.134
with a carpenter all the time.
00:11:59.774 --> 00:12:03.114
They may exchange their products and help
00:12:03.153 --> 00:12:03.595
each other,
00:12:04.274 --> 00:12:06.355
but being coordinated is a new thing.
00:12:06.674 --> 00:12:08.514
And so you get kind of two issues
00:12:08.554 --> 00:12:08.794
there.
00:12:08.956 --> 00:12:10.775
One is you teach them how to make
00:12:11.475 --> 00:12:12.436
military equipment,
00:12:13.076 --> 00:12:15.277
but you also teach them how to coordinate
00:12:15.297 --> 00:12:15.677
their work.
00:12:17.879 --> 00:12:19.520
there any uh women involved in this
00:12:19.561 --> 00:12:21.721
process rolling cartridges doing other
00:12:21.763 --> 00:12:23.844
kinds of work like that there might have
00:12:23.864 --> 00:12:25.785
been on the home front there are and
00:12:25.826 --> 00:12:27.386
that's kind of the exciting part is to
00:12:27.508 --> 00:12:32.111
see how um the process expands because it
00:12:32.131 --> 00:12:35.534
will start with these small operations in
00:12:35.575 --> 00:12:36.855
philadelphia and carlisle
00:12:38.125 --> 00:12:41.008
in seventeen seventy seven and then by
00:12:41.067 --> 00:12:42.028
seventeen seventy nine.
00:12:42.107 --> 00:12:45.750
It's this huge operation with four hundred
00:12:45.950 --> 00:12:50.552
government employees and then thousands of
00:12:50.633 --> 00:12:54.875
workers spread across different types of
00:12:54.914 --> 00:12:58.876
manufacturers, iron furnaces, gunsmiths.
00:13:02.113 --> 00:13:04.214
charcoal makers, miners,
00:13:04.615 --> 00:13:06.395
all kinds of private operations.
00:13:06.995 --> 00:13:07.875
And so within that,
00:13:07.917 --> 00:13:11.599
you have different groups.
00:13:11.678 --> 00:13:13.259
And again,
00:13:13.320 --> 00:13:15.561
one of the fun stories is the women
00:13:15.581 --> 00:13:21.004
that work at the Philadelphia Arsenal.
00:13:21.724 --> 00:13:24.485
So they are hired to make gun cartridges.
00:13:25.692 --> 00:13:27.033
at the Fifth Street Laboratory.
00:13:29.514 --> 00:13:32.437
And they are the most prolific producers
00:13:33.298 --> 00:13:36.840
of ammunition.
00:13:37.120 --> 00:13:38.302
And so at that laboratory,
00:13:38.322 --> 00:13:41.283
what they'll do is they'll bring in the
00:13:42.345 --> 00:13:44.525
separate pieces of the gunpowder and the
00:13:44.566 --> 00:13:45.067
bullets.
00:13:45.206 --> 00:13:48.649
They make the bullets at a furnace on
00:13:48.688 --> 00:13:49.629
the other side of town.
00:13:50.311 --> 00:13:51.932
They bring in the pre-cut paper.
00:13:53.136 --> 00:13:55.758
the papers cut at the ordinance yard and
00:13:55.837 --> 00:13:59.958
they'll supply it to women at rolling
00:13:59.999 --> 00:14:02.259
tables and the women will roll these
00:14:03.240 --> 00:14:07.100
cartridges and several men will pack them
00:14:07.160 --> 00:14:09.561
up and ship them off to the front.
00:14:10.001 --> 00:14:11.942
And of course, again,
00:14:12.001 --> 00:14:13.903
one of the fun things as I was
00:14:13.982 --> 00:14:14.962
going through all of this,
00:14:16.248 --> 00:14:18.808
uh the original research is finding betsy
00:14:18.849 --> 00:14:22.149
ross was employed for at least a time
00:14:22.210 --> 00:14:24.169
she made a couple hundred she wasn't
00:14:24.190 --> 00:14:27.350
employed there very long but she was at
00:14:27.370 --> 00:14:31.331
the fifth street laboratory um and helped
00:14:31.392 --> 00:14:34.293
make cartridges and then the most prolific
00:14:34.673 --> 00:14:38.453
manufacturer was um a young woman she made
00:14:38.734 --> 00:14:40.554
out of eleven million cartridges made by
00:14:40.634 --> 00:14:41.794
the um
00:14:43.506 --> 00:14:45.467
uh by the continental establishment she
00:14:45.508 --> 00:14:47.009
made two hundred and fifty thousand of
00:14:47.048 --> 00:14:51.652
them wow that's amazing do you remember
00:14:51.692 --> 00:14:55.072
her name i don't i should i have
00:14:55.092 --> 00:14:58.375
to yeah that's great we're talking with
00:14:58.414 --> 00:15:00.456
bob smith whose book is manufacturing
00:15:00.515 --> 00:15:02.977
independence industrial innovation in the
00:15:03.018 --> 00:15:05.078
american revolution now
00:15:05.663 --> 00:15:07.825
You mentioned that the Americans kind of
00:15:07.904 --> 00:15:10.667
model their establishment on Woolwich and
00:15:10.706 --> 00:15:11.307
the British,
00:15:11.648 --> 00:15:13.610
but then their chief allies here are the
00:15:13.649 --> 00:15:13.990
French.
00:15:14.029 --> 00:15:16.633
I'm wondering if there's any either
00:15:16.832 --> 00:15:20.076
tension or collaboration with the French
00:15:20.296 --> 00:15:21.917
in building these arsenals, because they,
00:15:21.956 --> 00:15:22.258
of course,
00:15:22.317 --> 00:15:25.461
also had a long experience in creating
00:15:25.541 --> 00:15:25.961
armaments.
00:15:27.096 --> 00:15:29.136
Yes, so there is some exchange.
00:15:29.797 --> 00:15:32.336
The French do not get heavily involved,
00:15:33.577 --> 00:15:37.178
not for any specific reason.
00:15:39.500 --> 00:15:41.679
They are, at the time,
00:15:42.980 --> 00:15:45.841
they are redeveloping their own government
00:15:45.860 --> 00:15:47.922
manufacturing or military manufacturing.
00:15:48.788 --> 00:15:50.870
element and so part of why they're willing
00:15:50.909 --> 00:15:53.591
to give us equipment is because they want
00:15:53.611 --> 00:15:55.273
to get rid of it they're trying to
00:15:55.312 --> 00:15:56.894
get rid of some of their old equipment
00:15:58.014 --> 00:16:00.155
um and so they're really focused on
00:16:00.176 --> 00:16:02.477
themselves they're not really too worried
00:16:02.498 --> 00:16:05.200
about us they can give us items that's
00:16:05.259 --> 00:16:07.821
all well and good and that's of course
00:16:07.860 --> 00:16:10.363
then the premise of how we end up
00:16:10.383 --> 00:16:14.706
with this process is we say that again
00:16:14.725 --> 00:16:16.047
historically we say that the french
00:16:17.028 --> 00:16:19.552
provide us with all of this equipment for
00:16:19.591 --> 00:16:20.312
the war effort,
00:16:21.214 --> 00:16:23.037
the majority of what the French give us
00:16:23.076 --> 00:16:26.743
is unusable, which I can come back to.
00:16:27.344 --> 00:16:28.404
For your specific question,
00:16:29.166 --> 00:16:30.488
we do get influences.
00:16:32.330 --> 00:16:35.611
a gentleman named Louis de Portal.
00:16:37.032 --> 00:16:40.453
He is an engineer that had worked with
00:16:40.634 --> 00:16:44.475
the French system of patterns and
00:16:44.995 --> 00:16:48.756
interchangeable parts that Groubeval was
00:16:48.837 --> 00:16:49.337
creating.
00:16:51.278 --> 00:16:51.538
But
00:16:52.509 --> 00:16:54.149
Does he have a huge influence?
00:16:54.789 --> 00:16:55.471
Not really.
00:16:55.530 --> 00:16:58.332
He probably does exchange.
00:16:58.373 --> 00:17:00.014
We know that he meets with men like
00:17:00.774 --> 00:17:03.176
Henry Knox and with George Washington.
00:17:03.875 --> 00:17:06.377
But the real influence is what the
00:17:06.417 --> 00:17:09.338
Americans know about the British system,
00:17:09.779 --> 00:17:12.461
which they get from a gentleman named John
00:17:12.500 --> 00:17:12.862
Mueller.
00:17:13.662 --> 00:17:18.542
who was chief mathematics professor at
00:17:18.603 --> 00:17:19.002
Woolwich.
00:17:19.182 --> 00:17:20.864
So he was the man that was teaching
00:17:21.604 --> 00:17:24.444
the British gunners how to operate the
00:17:24.484 --> 00:17:24.944
cannons.
00:17:24.984 --> 00:17:27.424
And then he was telling the Woolwich
00:17:28.226 --> 00:17:31.125
manufacturers how to make the cannons that
00:17:31.165 --> 00:17:32.346
could be most effective.
00:17:32.707 --> 00:17:34.426
And he was trying to make the processes
00:17:34.507 --> 00:17:34.826
better.
00:17:35.326 --> 00:17:37.587
And the Americans get his book, books.
00:17:39.347 --> 00:17:41.009
And that's really...
00:17:42.509 --> 00:17:46.191
where the influences come from that's it's
00:17:46.290 --> 00:17:49.752
interesting so then um how big is this
00:17:49.913 --> 00:17:53.154
establishment by the time say by seventeen
00:17:53.174 --> 00:17:55.155
eighty one seventy eighty two I mean the
00:17:55.256 --> 00:17:58.196
you mentioned you know thousands of these
00:17:58.596 --> 00:18:00.897
guy met people working and four hundred
00:18:00.938 --> 00:18:03.640
government employees all at work in these
00:18:03.700 --> 00:18:04.160
arsenals
00:18:05.854 --> 00:18:07.575
Yeah, it's pretty extensive.
00:18:07.714 --> 00:18:10.057
So the high point is really in the
00:18:10.076 --> 00:18:11.478
beginning of the year.
00:18:13.519 --> 00:18:15.119
You've got the three main arsenals,
00:18:15.259 --> 00:18:18.843
Philadelphia, Carlisle, and Springfield.
00:18:18.923 --> 00:18:21.944
You've got two minor arsenals.
00:18:22.265 --> 00:18:24.405
One is at Albany in New York,
00:18:24.425 --> 00:18:28.249
and the other is at West Ham in
00:18:28.269 --> 00:18:30.651
Virginia, just outside of Richmond.
00:18:31.230 --> 00:18:32.531
It's actually not at West Ham at that
00:18:32.571 --> 00:18:32.832
point.
00:18:32.892 --> 00:18:33.992
It's still moving around.
00:18:36.535 --> 00:18:38.876
But then in association with that,
00:18:38.916 --> 00:18:40.018
you have contractors.
00:18:40.239 --> 00:18:45.163
So at the major urban areas and then
00:18:45.284 --> 00:18:46.404
at the arsenals themselves,
00:18:46.424 --> 00:18:48.106
you have these commissaries.
00:18:49.268 --> 00:18:52.892
And these military stores commissaries are
00:18:52.932 --> 00:18:55.013
purchasers, essentially.
00:18:55.173 --> 00:18:56.695
Right.
00:18:59.113 --> 00:19:02.415
they will make contracts for items that
00:19:03.036 --> 00:19:05.238
the military establishment itself can't
00:19:05.298 --> 00:19:05.557
make.
00:19:05.637 --> 00:19:10.181
And so the real big one is cannons.
00:19:10.922 --> 00:19:12.823
The government never creates,
00:19:12.843 --> 00:19:16.665
never builds, never buys a blast furnace.
00:19:16.685 --> 00:19:19.689
There's too much expense that goes into
00:19:19.729 --> 00:19:19.828
it.
00:19:20.528 --> 00:19:23.550
And so they will contract with Hopewell
00:19:23.570 --> 00:19:25.333
Furnace, with Cornwall Furnace.
00:19:28.134 --> 00:19:30.537
Salisbury furnace in Connecticut,
00:19:31.557 --> 00:19:34.861
Batstow furnace in New Jersey,
00:19:37.222 --> 00:19:37.943
and several others.
00:19:39.721 --> 00:19:41.863
And so you have all the workers that
00:19:41.903 --> 00:19:42.343
are there.
00:19:43.002 --> 00:19:45.243
And then you have contractors in
00:19:45.463 --> 00:19:48.285
Springfield, Massachusetts, in Hartford,
00:19:48.345 --> 00:19:52.567
throughout the Connecticut River Valley.
00:19:53.166 --> 00:19:57.229
You've got dozens of contractors in
00:19:57.269 --> 00:19:57.868
Philadelphia.
00:19:57.949 --> 00:20:00.809
You've got contractors in Western
00:20:00.849 --> 00:20:01.450
Pennsylvania.
00:20:01.470 --> 00:20:03.151
So not just Carlisle, but Lancaster.
00:20:03.691 --> 00:20:06.071
And so all of their manufacturers are also
00:20:06.832 --> 00:20:07.712
employing people.
00:20:10.753 --> 00:20:12.315
And then aside from that,
00:20:12.375 --> 00:20:16.657
you just have your purchases that the
00:20:16.798 --> 00:20:17.597
commissaries make.
00:20:18.338 --> 00:20:20.079
And so they're just going out to
00:20:21.079 --> 00:20:24.001
manufacturers that aren't being contracted
00:20:24.021 --> 00:20:25.603
with and they're buying coal,
00:20:25.643 --> 00:20:26.983
they're buying charcoal,
00:20:27.003 --> 00:20:33.468
they're buying steel for bayonets.
00:20:34.469 --> 00:20:36.269
Are the Americans manufacturing steel at
00:20:36.289 --> 00:20:37.351
this time or does that have to be
00:20:37.371 --> 00:20:37.770
important?
00:20:38.857 --> 00:20:39.238
They are.
00:20:39.419 --> 00:20:40.699
It's a difficult process.
00:20:42.320 --> 00:20:42.681
I mean,
00:20:42.760 --> 00:20:44.382
it's nowhere near as easy as it's going
00:20:44.402 --> 00:20:47.723
to be at the end of the nineteenth
00:20:47.763 --> 00:20:48.184
century.
00:20:49.484 --> 00:20:51.166
And that's why they have to buy it
00:20:51.406 --> 00:20:52.528
in small quantities.
00:20:54.659 --> 00:20:55.500
And again,
00:20:55.519 --> 00:20:58.342
think about a place where you have the
00:20:58.442 --> 00:20:58.843
arsenal.
00:20:58.883 --> 00:20:59.083
I mean,
00:20:59.202 --> 00:21:00.964
all of these materials and all of these
00:21:01.005 --> 00:21:02.586
goods aren't necessarily there.
00:21:02.605 --> 00:21:04.748
So this also involves creating kind of a
00:21:04.788 --> 00:21:06.849
supply line to bring things to the place
00:21:06.869 --> 00:21:09.112
where the thing can be manufactured.
00:21:09.132 --> 00:21:09.673
That's correct.
00:21:09.772 --> 00:21:11.534
And that plays into...
00:21:12.807 --> 00:21:14.249
So,
00:21:14.828 --> 00:21:17.029
part of why the department reaches its
00:21:17.049 --> 00:21:19.711
high point is then, after that,
00:21:19.730 --> 00:21:22.071
the government starts cutting funding.
00:21:22.951 --> 00:21:23.491
And so,
00:21:23.952 --> 00:21:25.153
the government essentially declares
00:21:25.192 --> 00:21:27.134
bankruptcy, it refunds its debt,
00:21:29.134 --> 00:21:30.295
stops printing money,
00:21:31.036 --> 00:21:33.215
it tries to rely on taxes,
00:21:33.676 --> 00:21:33.896
which
00:21:34.923 --> 00:21:38.426
are unreliable, state grants, can't do it.
00:21:39.126 --> 00:21:42.509
And so the military stores department is
00:21:42.568 --> 00:21:43.789
kind of stuck in this lurch.
00:21:45.191 --> 00:21:47.413
And one of the kind of amazing things
00:21:48.294 --> 00:21:49.453
is how they overcome this.
00:21:49.513 --> 00:21:50.914
And if you look at like the quartermaster
00:21:50.934 --> 00:21:52.375
department, the commissary department,
00:21:53.116 --> 00:21:54.198
they don't do these things.
00:21:56.439 --> 00:21:58.099
They don't figure out a way to overcome
00:21:58.140 --> 00:21:59.000
not having money.
00:21:59.381 --> 00:22:00.761
What happens in the military stores
00:22:00.781 --> 00:22:03.584
department is that they have these
00:22:03.624 --> 00:22:04.005
workers.
00:22:04.998 --> 00:22:09.020
and so they can make stuff and this
00:22:09.280 --> 00:22:12.143
these items they can then trade and one
00:22:12.182 --> 00:22:14.744
of those as you point out is transport
00:22:15.286 --> 00:22:19.669
so what you see the department do is
00:22:20.009 --> 00:22:23.551
the craftsmen will make wagons wagons
00:22:23.592 --> 00:22:26.193
especially at carlisle and springfield
00:22:27.314 --> 00:22:28.894
They will make ammunition wagons.
00:22:29.734 --> 00:22:33.017
And I say that typically we have the
00:22:33.057 --> 00:22:35.738
Conestoga wagon in our minds when we think
00:22:35.778 --> 00:22:36.858
about early America.
00:22:38.019 --> 00:22:40.019
And we're not thinking about those big,
00:22:40.079 --> 00:22:41.661
heavy wagons.
00:22:41.681 --> 00:22:44.961
We're thinking that are carrying people's
00:22:45.021 --> 00:22:46.442
lives as they're traveling west.
00:22:47.042 --> 00:22:49.503
We're talking about simple transport.
00:22:49.523 --> 00:22:52.665
So just these big open wagons that can
00:22:52.705 --> 00:22:54.747
carry lots of boxes and equipment.
00:22:55.547 --> 00:22:59.710
And they will build those at those two
00:22:59.851 --> 00:23:04.673
outlying arsenals and then ship things to
00:23:04.713 --> 00:23:07.336
the center, to Philadelphia, to Richmond,
00:23:08.297 --> 00:23:10.259
to the front, to Washington's army.
00:23:11.530 --> 00:23:12.311
in New Jersey.
00:23:12.692 --> 00:23:13.894
And as they're moving through those
00:23:13.933 --> 00:23:17.558
places, they can pick up supplies,
00:23:17.598 --> 00:23:20.402
they can pick up contracted products,
00:23:21.022 --> 00:23:21.983
and you can write that,
00:23:22.003 --> 00:23:23.625
you can build that into the contract.
00:23:23.767 --> 00:23:25.909
And so instead of having to pay a
00:23:25.949 --> 00:23:27.191
manufacturer for
00:23:29.653 --> 00:23:30.712
all of that overhead.
00:23:31.113 --> 00:23:32.212
If you provide the overhead,
00:23:32.272 --> 00:23:35.074
you just have to pay the manufacturer for
00:23:36.335 --> 00:23:39.516
his profit because aside from transport,
00:23:40.076 --> 00:23:41.977
you can provide them with the raw
00:23:42.017 --> 00:23:43.477
materials because you can send your
00:23:43.517 --> 00:23:45.738
soldiers out to, which they do,
00:23:45.857 --> 00:23:47.919
they send their soldiers out to Wyoming
00:23:47.959 --> 00:23:50.038
Valley and out to Pittsburgh to mine coal,
00:23:51.759 --> 00:23:53.579
out to central Pennsylvania to get lead.
00:23:55.921 --> 00:24:01.042
they will purchase iron from furnaces.
00:24:01.083 --> 00:24:03.784
Or if a furnace gets a bad batch
00:24:04.003 --> 00:24:05.565
of cannons that burst,
00:24:05.944 --> 00:24:07.345
they can take all of that iron and
00:24:07.384 --> 00:24:09.185
give it to blacksmiths and pay them in
00:24:09.486 --> 00:24:09.746
iron.
00:24:09.786 --> 00:24:12.586
And that saves them actual cash.
00:24:13.207 --> 00:24:14.988
And so then they can create this entire
00:24:15.048 --> 00:24:17.189
network of trade.
00:24:19.416 --> 00:24:20.357
That's interesting.
00:24:20.377 --> 00:24:21.498
We're talking with Bob Smith,
00:24:21.577 --> 00:24:23.500
author of Manufacturing Independence,
00:24:23.539 --> 00:24:25.201
Industrial Innovation in the American
00:24:25.260 --> 00:24:25.820
Revolution.
00:24:26.480 --> 00:24:27.942
And we're being sponsored today by the
00:24:27.981 --> 00:24:30.183
Richard Lounsbury Foundation to have this
00:24:30.243 --> 00:24:33.005
conversation about industrial innovation
00:24:33.185 --> 00:24:34.465
in the American Revolution.
00:24:35.247 --> 00:24:37.208
That's interesting the way they then use
00:24:37.248 --> 00:24:39.128
these things they're making actually to
00:24:39.189 --> 00:24:42.111
decrease the overhead of the contractors,
00:24:42.131 --> 00:24:43.352
the manufacturers and all.
00:24:44.102 --> 00:24:45.724
Does this have an effect then after the
00:24:45.744 --> 00:24:45.964
war?
00:24:46.005 --> 00:24:46.144
I mean,
00:24:46.164 --> 00:24:47.887
you've created these networks and you've
00:24:47.907 --> 00:24:50.653
had these craftsmen in Springfield and
00:24:50.692 --> 00:24:51.314
Carlisle,
00:24:51.334 --> 00:24:53.517
these other places after the war.
00:24:53.557 --> 00:24:55.460
Does it all shut down or what happens
00:24:55.500 --> 00:24:56.321
to all of these guys?
00:24:57.289 --> 00:24:59.392
So there's a struggle that happens.
00:24:59.731 --> 00:25:00.952
So there's kind of two sides of the
00:25:00.972 --> 00:25:01.273
story.
00:25:01.453 --> 00:25:03.174
One is the struggle that happens within
00:25:03.194 --> 00:25:05.156
the Continental government and then
00:25:05.196 --> 00:25:08.500
ultimately the federal government with
00:25:08.539 --> 00:25:09.760
what to do with all of this.
00:25:10.261 --> 00:25:13.223
Because Congress and especially
00:25:15.486 --> 00:25:17.988
the major leaders of the war effort.
00:25:18.107 --> 00:25:20.329
And so by the end of the war,
00:25:20.730 --> 00:25:22.851
it's specifically Benjamin Lincoln.
00:25:22.990 --> 00:25:25.413
Benjamin Lincoln becomes the first
00:25:25.432 --> 00:25:29.056
Secretary of War in a reorganized
00:25:29.276 --> 00:25:30.957
bureaucracy within the Continental
00:25:30.977 --> 00:25:31.356
Government.
00:25:31.777 --> 00:25:33.598
And he's followed by Henry Knox.
00:25:35.119 --> 00:25:37.401
And Henry Knox had helped create this
00:25:37.441 --> 00:25:38.561
system in the first place.
00:25:38.602 --> 00:25:40.903
And so both of these men recognize
00:25:41.896 --> 00:25:43.077
we put a lot of effort,
00:25:43.278 --> 00:25:45.599
a lot of money in building this thing
00:25:45.619 --> 00:25:46.260
from scratch.
00:25:47.442 --> 00:25:50.744
And they recognized also that it took us
00:25:50.805 --> 00:25:51.184
time.
00:25:51.785 --> 00:25:55.048
So the war begins in April of seventeen
00:25:55.107 --> 00:25:55.868
seventy seven.
00:25:56.368 --> 00:25:59.811
We don't have this process in place until
00:26:00.792 --> 00:26:01.554
seventy five.
00:26:01.953 --> 00:26:06.076
I said I'm sorry until seventy seven.
00:26:07.038 --> 00:26:08.480
And really, you know,
00:26:08.519 --> 00:26:10.482
it's not really functioning efficiently
00:26:10.583 --> 00:26:11.525
until seventy nine.
00:26:11.605 --> 00:26:15.190
And so why would we dismantle it and
00:26:15.809 --> 00:26:17.792
have to do it again when we're going
00:26:17.813 --> 00:26:18.815
to go to war again?
00:26:18.835 --> 00:26:19.154
I mean,
00:26:19.434 --> 00:26:22.740
it's a function of a government in their
00:26:22.779 --> 00:26:23.059
minds.
00:26:24.300 --> 00:26:26.041
and so to go to war but to
00:26:26.461 --> 00:26:28.742
fight one if one if correct correct yeah
00:26:29.542 --> 00:26:32.824
and so there's this big push among these
00:26:32.884 --> 00:26:35.105
men to keep this going we can't let
00:26:35.144 --> 00:26:37.645
this fall apart we can't let what we've
00:26:37.685 --> 00:26:39.386
learned and so um
00:26:40.567 --> 00:26:42.428
Benjamin Lincoln writes this huge report
00:26:42.448 --> 00:26:43.188
to Congress,
00:26:43.969 --> 00:26:48.990
which down the road becomes Alexander
00:26:49.010 --> 00:26:52.992
Hamilton's report on manufacturers that we
00:26:53.032 --> 00:26:56.795
can't ignore the resources we have and
00:26:57.075 --> 00:26:59.736
trust that if and when we go to
00:26:59.776 --> 00:27:00.175
war,
00:27:01.176 --> 00:27:04.137
our allies or our trading partners are
00:27:04.157 --> 00:27:05.199
going to be able to
00:27:06.327 --> 00:27:07.588
provide us.
00:27:08.028 --> 00:27:09.410
So that's one.
00:27:09.529 --> 00:27:10.211
And ultimately,
00:27:11.510 --> 00:27:13.893
the government does agree to keep it open.
00:27:14.993 --> 00:27:15.973
Funding is minimal,
00:27:16.575 --> 00:27:19.096
but it survives the Confederation period.
00:27:19.135 --> 00:27:22.317
And then Henry Knox,
00:27:22.337 --> 00:27:24.220
when he's become Secretary of War in
00:27:24.259 --> 00:27:24.839
Washington,
00:27:25.480 --> 00:27:27.922
he helps rebuild the system in the way
00:27:27.961 --> 00:27:29.462
he really wanted it from the beginning.
00:27:34.056 --> 00:27:36.416
And the fun continuity on both sides,
00:27:36.616 --> 00:27:39.799
one is that Springfield becomes the armory
00:27:41.500 --> 00:27:43.461
that it eventually develops into.
00:27:45.442 --> 00:27:49.365
And the commanders at the armory,
00:27:49.665 --> 00:27:51.467
when it's created under Knox,
00:27:52.748 --> 00:27:55.150
are holdovers from the Arsenal period
00:27:55.170 --> 00:27:55.809
during the war.
00:27:56.490 --> 00:28:00.252
The same thing is true with the armory
00:28:00.272 --> 00:28:02.454
that's built at Harpers Ferry.
00:28:03.315 --> 00:28:05.136
Harper's Ferry is going to be managed,
00:28:05.176 --> 00:28:07.137
the first manager of the Harper's Ferry
00:28:07.198 --> 00:28:10.921
Armory when it starts in seventeen ninety
00:28:10.980 --> 00:28:16.265
seven is the commander of the armory in
00:28:16.325 --> 00:28:18.205
Philadelphia during the war.
00:28:18.886 --> 00:28:20.948
And so it's a direct connection.
00:28:21.429 --> 00:28:24.851
The other major development is just the
00:28:24.891 --> 00:28:26.432
manufacturing base that's created.
00:28:26.692 --> 00:28:27.973
And so, I mean, it's no
00:28:29.875 --> 00:28:31.717
it shouldn't be a surprise that
00:28:31.797 --> 00:28:33.679
Philadelphia is the workshop of the world
00:28:36.101 --> 00:28:40.984
develops in the period after you have this
00:28:41.125 --> 00:28:43.248
manufacturing boom during the war.
00:28:43.988 --> 00:28:45.229
And these men
00:28:47.397 --> 00:28:48.679
who had been contractors.
00:28:49.199 --> 00:28:52.300
They have learned how to manufacture based
00:28:52.340 --> 00:28:54.001
on what the government had done with its
00:28:54.622 --> 00:28:56.542
organized operations in Philadelphia.
00:28:58.104 --> 00:28:59.424
They've sold their products to the
00:28:59.464 --> 00:28:59.904
government.
00:29:00.444 --> 00:29:02.346
They have been part of this system.
00:29:02.445 --> 00:29:04.748
And then they apply these lessons after
00:29:04.788 --> 00:29:05.228
the war.
00:29:06.808 --> 00:29:12.571
And you've really built a proletarian
00:29:12.612 --> 00:29:15.733
workforce, this unskilled workforce.
00:29:16.637 --> 00:29:18.117
that is able to find jobs.
00:29:18.157 --> 00:29:22.680
And that's a huge difference post-war from
00:29:22.720 --> 00:29:23.660
the pre-war era.
00:29:24.279 --> 00:29:25.220
During the colonial period,
00:29:25.240 --> 00:29:26.800
the United States does not have the
00:29:27.800 --> 00:29:28.861
population base,
00:29:29.281 --> 00:29:32.061
the consumer base to buy the products that
00:29:32.261 --> 00:29:34.663
we manufacture in large numbers, clothing,
00:29:35.063 --> 00:29:35.623
weapons,
00:29:37.344 --> 00:29:39.723
anything metal that blacksmiths make.
00:29:39.923 --> 00:29:41.265
After the war, that changes.
00:29:41.724 --> 00:29:44.226
Americans are opened up to these products.
00:29:45.705 --> 00:29:47.307
As you asked the question earlier about
00:29:47.326 --> 00:29:48.468
the transport networks,
00:29:49.009 --> 00:29:51.730
suddenly manufacturers recognize what's
00:29:51.770 --> 00:29:52.211
available.
00:29:52.491 --> 00:29:52.632
Oh,
00:29:52.711 --> 00:29:55.554
we can get lead and charcoal and coal
00:29:55.574 --> 00:29:58.175
from the frontier and it's easily
00:29:58.215 --> 00:29:59.176
accessible.
00:30:01.301 --> 00:30:03.064
because we've built these networks during
00:30:03.084 --> 00:30:05.806
the war itself.
00:30:05.826 --> 00:30:07.208
So those are the two ways that really
00:30:07.468 --> 00:30:08.969
it does continue after the war.
00:30:09.249 --> 00:30:10.069
That's interesting.
00:30:10.089 --> 00:30:11.290
We're talking with Bob Smith,
00:30:11.330 --> 00:30:13.413
who is the provost and chief academic
00:30:13.512 --> 00:30:15.714
officer at Valley Forge College in Valley
00:30:15.755 --> 00:30:16.796
Forge, Pennsylvania,
00:30:17.316 --> 00:30:18.998
and also the author of Manufacturing
00:30:19.057 --> 00:30:20.859
Independence, Industrial Innovation,
00:30:20.900 --> 00:30:22.141
and the American Revolution.
00:30:22.641 --> 00:30:24.702
And our conversation today is sponsored by
00:30:24.742 --> 00:30:26.364
the Richard Lounsbury Foundation.
00:30:27.874 --> 00:30:30.797
So, Bob, I also am thinking in our,
00:30:30.957 --> 00:30:32.617
the way, at the beginning,
00:30:32.637 --> 00:30:34.200
you talked about kind of the mythology and
00:30:34.220 --> 00:30:36.240
part of the mythology of American
00:30:36.561 --> 00:30:38.542
inventiveness are people like the
00:30:38.563 --> 00:30:40.904
character, Eli Whitney or Robert Fulton.
00:30:41.705 --> 00:30:46.150
And this seems to be a bit different,
00:30:46.170 --> 00:30:47.030
but I want to ask first,
00:30:47.131 --> 00:30:49.772
are there any individuals who stand out
00:30:49.813 --> 00:30:50.534
here as like,
00:30:50.614 --> 00:30:52.734
this is the central character in the
00:30:52.776 --> 00:30:53.135
story?
00:30:54.829 --> 00:30:56.431
So my favorite,
00:30:56.451 --> 00:30:58.192
and I think one of my heroes,
00:30:58.732 --> 00:30:59.673
is Samuel Hodgdon.
00:31:02.174 --> 00:31:03.435
He's not really an innovator.
00:31:05.737 --> 00:31:06.798
He's really a manager.
00:31:08.638 --> 00:31:09.980
Before I talk about him, I mean,
00:31:11.520 --> 00:31:16.924
specific to men like Fulton and Eli
00:31:16.944 --> 00:31:18.685
Whitney, you know,
00:31:18.925 --> 00:31:22.667
these great dreamers that have these...
00:31:24.917 --> 00:31:25.818
Grand ideas.
00:31:26.239 --> 00:31:27.519
There's really nobody like that.
00:31:29.882 --> 00:31:30.821
Maybe Henry Knox.
00:31:30.902 --> 00:31:32.222
I'm not a huge fan of Henry Knox.
00:31:32.242 --> 00:31:34.244
You're not a huge fan of Henry Knox.
00:31:34.625 --> 00:31:35.025
I'm not.
00:31:36.826 --> 00:31:42.451
That'll be another episode.
00:31:42.530 --> 00:31:43.652
And only in this context.
00:31:43.692 --> 00:31:45.452
Not generally.
00:31:47.453 --> 00:31:49.895
Because I think his vision for what's
00:31:49.935 --> 00:31:52.617
possible with this is somewhat limited.
00:31:52.657 --> 00:31:53.558
But
00:31:56.472 --> 00:31:59.978
he he does see the the value of
00:32:00.198 --> 00:32:06.747
manufacturing um but do they change the
00:32:06.847 --> 00:32:10.732
nature of of work no um
00:32:11.703 --> 00:32:13.526
Do they change the nature of the
00:32:13.605 --> 00:32:15.488
relationship between government and
00:32:15.628 --> 00:32:16.328
manufacturers?
00:32:16.390 --> 00:32:16.809
Yes.
00:32:17.611 --> 00:32:19.373
And that's really where Samuel Hodgson
00:32:19.413 --> 00:32:19.913
comes in.
00:32:21.935 --> 00:32:25.440
Whitney makes his fortune as a government
00:32:25.480 --> 00:32:27.663
contractor.
00:32:27.682 --> 00:32:29.545
That's more important for him than the
00:32:29.625 --> 00:32:30.105
cotton gin.
00:32:30.925 --> 00:32:31.446
Personally.
00:32:31.967 --> 00:32:32.247
Right.
00:32:32.326 --> 00:32:36.770
But Samuel Hodgdon recognizes that if you
00:32:36.790 --> 00:32:39.192
can build this network of manufacturers
00:32:39.512 --> 00:32:42.414
and you can trade produce,
00:32:42.474 --> 00:32:45.837
you can build a commercial market that can
00:32:45.857 --> 00:32:47.900
then support what's going on.
00:32:47.920 --> 00:32:50.240
And he's he's the second manufacturer.
00:32:52.762 --> 00:32:54.463
Commissary General of Military Stores.
00:32:54.503 --> 00:32:56.065
The first one is Benjamin Flower,
00:32:57.244 --> 00:32:59.165
who is a great motivator.
00:33:00.727 --> 00:33:02.647
He recognizes that the government has to
00:33:02.688 --> 00:33:03.147
do this.
00:33:04.288 --> 00:33:06.930
It can't rely on individual producers
00:33:06.970 --> 00:33:08.590
because they just don't have the capacity.
00:33:11.471 --> 00:33:13.353
But it's really Samuel Hodgdon that
00:33:13.393 --> 00:33:14.874
understands process.
00:33:15.775 --> 00:33:16.414
Where is he from?
00:33:18.227 --> 00:33:19.930
He is from Pennsylvania.
00:33:21.152 --> 00:33:22.554
Not too much is known about him.
00:33:22.634 --> 00:33:24.316
I have seen some
00:33:26.169 --> 00:33:27.069
research recently,
00:33:28.029 --> 00:33:29.571
learning more about where he came from,
00:33:29.672 --> 00:33:31.992
but I'm not overly familiar with that.
00:33:32.032 --> 00:33:32.093
OK.
00:33:35.695 --> 00:33:36.517
I think, Jonathan,
00:33:36.576 --> 00:33:39.638
just as we are here in the great
00:33:39.778 --> 00:33:41.200
Commonwealth of Massachusetts,
00:33:41.220 --> 00:33:42.881
and Jonathan asked about Paul Revere,
00:33:42.902 --> 00:33:45.103
who also sets up a manufacturing,
00:33:45.844 --> 00:33:48.385
actually to roll copper for the hull of
00:33:48.465 --> 00:33:49.226
old Ironsides.
00:33:50.646 --> 00:33:51.228
So Jonathan,
00:33:51.688 --> 00:33:53.328
I guess after you knocked Henry Knox,
00:33:53.368 --> 00:33:55.009
Jonathan said, what about Paul Revere?
00:33:57.500 --> 00:33:59.788
No, Revere is a great example.
00:34:02.770 --> 00:34:04.531
He learns from the war effort,
00:34:05.413 --> 00:34:06.573
the value of manufacturing,
00:34:06.593 --> 00:34:09.094
and he changes his mindset.
00:34:09.135 --> 00:34:13.858
The war has a huge impact on what
00:34:13.918 --> 00:34:20.202
he recognizes as economical.
00:34:20.222 --> 00:34:21.561
What's the right word?
00:34:21.822 --> 00:34:22.603
It's a business model.
00:34:22.983 --> 00:34:26.105
He recognizes the business model because
00:34:26.144 --> 00:34:28.487
before the war, he is a craftsman.
00:34:29.146 --> 00:34:30.748
After the war, he is a manufacturer.
00:34:31.963 --> 00:34:32.864
Right, right.
00:34:33.523 --> 00:34:35.706
And that really is a tremendous change,
00:34:35.766 --> 00:34:37.969
which your book argues really comes about
00:34:38.048 --> 00:34:40.690
as a result of this building of this
00:34:40.831 --> 00:34:41.692
infrastructure,
00:34:41.731 --> 00:34:43.833
building of these bigger manufacturing
00:34:43.873 --> 00:34:46.617
establishments in places like Springfield,
00:34:46.657 --> 00:34:48.077
Carlisle, Philadelphia,
00:34:48.097 --> 00:34:50.599
that really are going to have this effect
00:34:50.780 --> 00:34:51.621
afterward,
00:34:51.681 --> 00:34:56.606
which turning the craftsmen into part of
00:34:56.626 --> 00:34:57.746
an industrial process.
00:34:59.177 --> 00:34:59.478
Yes,
00:34:59.597 --> 00:35:03.199
and if you look at the progress of
00:35:03.219 --> 00:35:04.219
the Industrial Revolution,
00:35:05.940 --> 00:35:11.402
David Hounsell talks about it in his great
00:35:11.442 --> 00:35:11.722
work.
00:35:12.782 --> 00:35:13.963
They start with,
00:35:13.983 --> 00:35:16.543
all historians and him in particular,
00:35:16.923 --> 00:35:19.905
they start with Samuel Slater.
00:35:19.925 --> 00:35:21.565
They start with the seventeen nineties.
00:35:22.405 --> 00:35:25.407
And I really got into this project because
00:35:25.447 --> 00:35:27.168
I wanted to see what happens before that.
00:35:29.273 --> 00:35:30.554
I refuse to believe, I mean,
00:35:30.715 --> 00:35:31.936
maybe that my own bias,
00:35:33.416 --> 00:35:37.639
I refuse to believe that just, you know,
00:35:37.679 --> 00:35:39.099
this one guy popping up,
00:35:39.820 --> 00:35:41.221
I believe that there was a process.
00:35:42.322 --> 00:35:46.123
And as transformationary, transformative,
00:35:46.543 --> 00:35:49.485
there's my PhD coming in,
00:35:49.505 --> 00:35:51.487
coming into play there with my grammar
00:35:51.507 --> 00:35:51.847
skills.
00:35:52.827 --> 00:35:55.429
As transformative as the American
00:35:55.469 --> 00:35:56.829
Revolution was politically,
00:36:00.190 --> 00:36:02.210
I believed that it had to have the
00:36:02.251 --> 00:36:03.791
same impact economically.
00:36:04.130 --> 00:36:07.692
And we weren't really looking at that as
00:36:07.731 --> 00:36:08.431
historians.
00:36:08.692 --> 00:36:11.932
And I think that's a huge deal for
00:36:11.992 --> 00:36:13.773
understanding the United States,
00:36:14.032 --> 00:36:17.634
because we do come to rely on this
00:36:17.693 --> 00:36:18.934
banking infrastructure and this
00:36:18.994 --> 00:36:20.554
manufacturing infrastructure.
00:36:21.315 --> 00:36:22.494
And there's a reason why,
00:36:23.394 --> 00:36:25.295
because we recognized during the war that
00:36:25.456 --> 00:36:26.976
we needed it for our independence.
00:36:28.251 --> 00:36:29.032
Right.
00:36:29.092 --> 00:36:30.713
And we certainly see that after other
00:36:30.793 --> 00:36:32.914
wars, War of eighteen twelve and then,
00:36:32.954 --> 00:36:33.293
of course,
00:36:33.313 --> 00:36:36.396
the Civil War and then the World Wars
00:36:36.436 --> 00:36:38.538
of the twentieth century kind of we see
00:36:38.577 --> 00:36:39.097
that.
00:36:39.237 --> 00:36:42.701
And so here it's fascinating that we
00:36:42.740 --> 00:36:44.641
hadn't really looked at this happening at
00:36:44.661 --> 00:36:46.503
the time of the revolution until
00:36:48.043 --> 00:36:48.304
I mean,
00:36:48.344 --> 00:36:49.704
there are a couple of other books that
00:36:49.724 --> 00:36:51.224
kind of mention this happening,
00:36:51.344 --> 00:36:54.326
but we don't really see the overall
00:36:54.405 --> 00:36:55.907
network that's created here.
00:36:55.947 --> 00:36:58.407
This industrial network being created is
00:36:58.447 --> 00:37:00.168
going to have a long impact.
00:37:00.827 --> 00:37:02.048
And I will point out,
00:37:02.088 --> 00:37:05.030
so I think this is a good spot.
00:37:05.570 --> 00:37:07.331
So it's actually Valley Forge Military
00:37:07.371 --> 00:37:07.731
College.
00:37:08.791 --> 00:37:09.391
I apologize.
00:37:09.431 --> 00:37:10.434
We went over that earlier.
00:37:11.934 --> 00:37:13.317
I just mentioned the college part,
00:37:14.197 --> 00:37:16.099
but I got to stress the military part.
00:37:17.161 --> 00:37:19.043
And I say that now because that is
00:37:19.063 --> 00:37:23.307
something we talk about in our military
00:37:23.347 --> 00:37:25.510
history courses and what our students are
00:37:25.550 --> 00:37:27.954
learning in our ROTC program.
00:37:32.085 --> 00:37:32.985
about the battlefield.
00:37:34.246 --> 00:37:37.969
It's about everything that surrounds that.
00:37:38.168 --> 00:37:42.952
And I think this story about the American
00:37:42.992 --> 00:37:43.532
Revolution,
00:37:44.032 --> 00:37:45.233
as we've talked about it so far,
00:37:46.534 --> 00:37:49.175
fits with what we know about later wars.
00:37:51.356 --> 00:37:52.056
Rich Atkinson,
00:37:53.717 --> 00:37:55.018
in his books about World War II,
00:37:57.500 --> 00:37:58.661
has pointed out,
00:37:58.902 --> 00:38:01.626
eighty percent of the armed forces were
00:38:01.666 --> 00:38:03.889
there to support the twenty percent that
00:38:03.929 --> 00:38:04.269
fought.
00:38:07.695 --> 00:38:09.538
And so war making is much more than
00:38:09.597 --> 00:38:09.938
just
00:38:11.155 --> 00:38:12.775
you know, the battlefields we learn about.
00:38:13.135 --> 00:38:16.338
What makes it possible for Washington to
00:38:16.699 --> 00:38:17.659
win Yorktown?
00:38:17.699 --> 00:38:19.981
Well, the cannons that this department,
00:38:20.021 --> 00:38:21.643
the military storage department creates,
00:38:22.322 --> 00:38:23.903
the ammunition that this department
00:38:23.943 --> 00:38:24.525
creates,
00:38:24.565 --> 00:38:27.126
the tools that this department creates,
00:38:27.686 --> 00:38:30.588
the money that the treasury department is
00:38:30.668 --> 00:38:32.811
able to organize,
00:38:33.210 --> 00:38:35.192
the transport that the quartermaster is
00:38:35.211 --> 00:38:36.032
able to organize.
00:38:36.413 --> 00:38:36.913
None of that
00:38:37.893 --> 00:38:38.655
Without any of that,
00:38:38.715 --> 00:38:41.576
he's not moving his army and laying siege
00:38:41.596 --> 00:38:43.958
to Cornwallis at Yorktown.
00:38:43.978 --> 00:38:45.139
Think about those eleven million
00:38:45.199 --> 00:38:45.918
cartridges.
00:38:46.800 --> 00:38:47.139
Also,
00:38:47.159 --> 00:38:48.900
it just occurs to me that Stalin at
00:38:49.061 --> 00:38:53.623
one of the closing months gatherings
00:38:53.664 --> 00:38:55.445
toasted American manufacturing,
00:38:55.465 --> 00:38:56.965
which made the victory possible.
00:38:58.126 --> 00:39:00.967
And so you have this creation here.
00:39:01.527 --> 00:39:03.708
We've been talking with Bob Smith from the
00:39:03.768 --> 00:39:05.510
Valley Forge Military College.
00:39:06.670 --> 00:39:07.391
Since you mentioned it,
00:39:07.431 --> 00:39:08.411
we want to tell us a little bit
00:39:08.451 --> 00:39:09.992
about Valley Forge Military College.
00:39:10.632 --> 00:39:10.931
Sure.
00:39:11.211 --> 00:39:14.375
So we are a small private institution.
00:39:14.914 --> 00:39:15.815
We're a junior college,
00:39:16.715 --> 00:39:19.818
meaning we have associate's degrees.
00:39:21.039 --> 00:39:24.001
But we prep students for what comes next
00:39:24.041 --> 00:39:24.702
in their lives.
00:39:24.782 --> 00:39:28.344
And so we've got three main programs.
00:39:28.623 --> 00:39:30.505
One is our early commissioning program,
00:39:31.166 --> 00:39:33.668
which is one of only four in the
00:39:33.708 --> 00:39:36.168
country where a student can complete their
00:39:36.769 --> 00:39:38.971
ROTC training in two years and earn a
00:39:39.010 --> 00:39:39.411
commission.
00:39:40.893 --> 00:39:42.155
uh before going on to finish their
00:39:42.175 --> 00:39:45.856
bachelor's degree um vice a traditional
00:39:45.876 --> 00:39:51.400
four-year rotc program at a larger type of
00:39:51.460 --> 00:39:53.842
school we also have a citizen leaders
00:39:53.882 --> 00:39:56.945
program where we teach what today is
00:39:56.965 --> 00:40:01.788
called soft skills so self-discipline
00:40:01.947 --> 00:40:06.590
self-motivation physical development moral
00:40:06.831 --> 00:40:09.213
ethical character development
00:40:11.454 --> 00:40:11.735
Really,
00:40:11.775 --> 00:40:14.976
it's a three-sixty model of building up
00:40:15.315 --> 00:40:16.637
students and then preparing them to
00:40:16.677 --> 00:40:20.159
transfer to their four-year institutions
00:40:20.639 --> 00:40:22.420
and finish their degrees.
00:40:23.139 --> 00:40:25.081
And then we have a Prepster program for
00:40:25.141 --> 00:40:26.081
the service academies.
00:40:26.181 --> 00:40:28.402
We're a partner with West Point,
00:40:28.443 --> 00:40:32.885
so any students that are looking to prep
00:40:32.925 --> 00:40:35.847
for a year to strengthen their candidacy
00:40:35.867 --> 00:40:38.307
to West Point can come to Valley Forge.
00:40:39.041 --> 00:40:40.523
So we're located right outside of
00:40:40.563 --> 00:40:42.304
Philadelphia in Wayne,
00:40:44.005 --> 00:40:46.809
right down the street from Valley Forge
00:40:46.829 --> 00:40:47.469
National Park.
00:40:48.670 --> 00:40:51.072
And yeah,
00:40:51.253 --> 00:40:53.253
we've sent students to some great follow
00:40:53.295 --> 00:40:57.597
on schools, to Baylor, to UNC,
00:40:58.898 --> 00:41:02.563
all of the Pennsylvania schools, Syracuse,
00:41:03.163 --> 00:41:03.583
Michigan.
00:41:04.875 --> 00:41:05.615
Just to name a few.
00:41:06.155 --> 00:41:08.157
I'm really proud of what our students have
00:41:08.177 --> 00:41:10.798
been able to go on and do.
00:41:10.838 --> 00:41:11.259
Very good.
00:41:11.318 --> 00:41:11.679
Thank you.
00:41:12.519 --> 00:41:14.842
So we've been talking with Bob Smith,
00:41:14.862 --> 00:41:16.523
who is the provost at Valley Forge
00:41:16.663 --> 00:41:18.543
Military College and the author of
00:41:18.603 --> 00:41:20.144
Manufacturing Independence,
00:41:20.184 --> 00:41:21.226
Industrial Innovation,
00:41:21.266 --> 00:41:22.407
and the American Revolution.
00:41:22.947 --> 00:41:24.728
And our conversation today is sponsored by
00:41:24.748 --> 00:41:26.449
the Richard Lounsbury Foundation.
00:41:27.050 --> 00:41:27.971
So thank you, Bob,
00:41:28.010 --> 00:41:28.951
so much for joining us.
00:41:29.152 --> 00:41:31.132
And we'll have to get you back on
00:41:31.532 --> 00:41:32.994
so we can defend Henry Knox.
00:41:35.936 --> 00:41:37.817
And I want to thank Jonathan Lane,
00:41:37.896 --> 00:41:39.818
our producer, the man behind the curtain.
00:41:40.217 --> 00:41:40.998
And every week, Bob,
00:41:41.079 --> 00:41:43.320
we thank folks who are regular listeners.
00:41:43.619 --> 00:41:45.041
And if you are in one of these
00:41:45.081 --> 00:41:47.362
places and want some of our Revolution two
00:41:47.382 --> 00:41:49.722
fifty stuff, send Jonathan an email.
00:41:49.762 --> 00:41:52.005
Jay Lane at Revolution two five zero dot
00:41:52.125 --> 00:41:52.244
org.
00:41:53.092 --> 00:41:54.733
and if you're not send him an email
00:41:54.773 --> 00:41:56.474
anyway he loves hearing from folks and
00:41:56.494 --> 00:41:58.134
this week i want to thank our listeners
00:41:58.193 --> 00:42:01.135
in laval and montreal in the province of
00:42:01.195 --> 00:42:03.956
quebec here in the bay state in hanover
00:42:03.996 --> 00:42:07.018
massachusetts in vestal new york barcelona
00:42:07.759 --> 00:42:09.938
and in summerfield north carolina thank
00:42:09.958 --> 00:42:11.360
you for joining us and thank you to
00:42:11.420 --> 00:42:13.521
all folks places between and beyond and
00:42:13.601 --> 00:42:15.222
now we will be piped out on the
00:42:15.262 --> 00:42:15.742
road to boston