Revolution 250 Podcast
Revolution 250 Podcast
John Dickinson: Penman of the Revolution with Jane Calvert
John Dickinson burst onto the scene with his "Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania" published in a Philadelphia newspaper in 1767 and 1768. He wrote "The Liberty Song," sung all over America, including at the 1769 Sons of Liberty dinner in Dorchester, Massachusetts, and the Continental Congress's Olive Branch Petition and with Jefferson the "Declaration on the Causes and Necessity of Taking Up Arms." While he opposed the Declaration of Independence, he drafted the Articles of Confederation, and in 1787 was a member of the Constitutional Convention. We talk about Dickinson with Dr. Jane Calvert, author of the new biography, Penman of the Founding: A Biography of John Dickinson , and the Director and Chief Editor of the John Dickinson Writings Project.
WEBVTT
00:00:01.772 --> 00:00:02.472
Hello, everyone.
00:00:02.532 --> 00:00:03.653
Welcome to the Revolution
00:00:03.693 --> 00:00:04.854
Two-Fifty podcast.
00:00:04.974 --> 00:00:05.735
I'm Bob Allison.
00:00:05.815 --> 00:00:06.655
I chair the Revolution
00:00:06.695 --> 00:00:08.055
Two-Fifty Advisory Group.
00:00:08.096 --> 00:00:09.797
We are a consortium of about
00:00:10.237 --> 00:00:10.977
seventy five or so
00:00:10.997 --> 00:00:11.819
organizations in
00:00:11.859 --> 00:00:13.060
Massachusetts planning ways
00:00:13.080 --> 00:00:13.720
to commemorate the
00:00:13.740 --> 00:00:15.641
beginnings of American independence.
00:00:16.141 --> 00:00:18.402
And our guest today is Jane E. Calvert.
00:00:18.903 --> 00:00:21.425
Jane Calvert is the director
00:00:21.464 --> 00:00:22.425
and chief editor of the
00:00:22.446 --> 00:00:23.527
John Dickinson Writing
00:00:23.567 --> 00:00:24.667
Project and the author of
00:00:25.007 --> 00:00:26.469
two books on John Dickinson,
00:00:26.528 --> 00:00:28.089
Quaker Constitutionalism
00:00:28.210 --> 00:00:29.030
and the Political Thought
00:00:29.070 --> 00:00:29.911
of John Dickinson.
00:00:30.527 --> 00:00:33.468
And her new book is Penman of the Founding,
00:00:34.548 --> 00:00:36.270
a biography of John Dickinson.
00:00:36.289 --> 00:00:38.651
So Jane, thank you so much for joining us.
00:00:38.670 --> 00:00:39.511
Thanks for inviting me.
00:00:40.551 --> 00:00:41.671
And so let me ask you first,
00:00:42.371 --> 00:00:43.512
Dickinson is a figure who
00:00:43.552 --> 00:00:44.573
looms very large at the
00:00:44.612 --> 00:00:46.154
time of the founding.
00:00:46.954 --> 00:00:50.115
And today he's somewhat obscure,
00:00:50.975 --> 00:00:52.256
but I wonder what drew you
00:00:52.296 --> 00:00:53.576
to him as a subject you
00:00:53.597 --> 00:00:54.878
wanted to spend the next, you know,
00:00:54.898 --> 00:00:56.759
twenty years of your life focusing on.
00:00:57.869 --> 00:00:58.090
Well,
00:00:58.871 --> 00:01:02.654
so I went into graduate school in
00:01:02.713 --> 00:01:04.656
history to study
00:01:04.876 --> 00:01:06.656
intellectual history and
00:01:06.757 --> 00:01:08.578
try to understand what's
00:01:08.618 --> 00:01:10.420
going on in America today
00:01:10.459 --> 00:01:11.661
by understanding the past.
00:01:12.322 --> 00:01:14.543
And I actually had no
00:01:14.584 --> 00:01:16.284
intention of studying the founding era.
00:01:16.364 --> 00:01:18.066
I was going to do colonial era.
00:01:21.269 --> 00:01:23.090
but I started working on
00:01:23.131 --> 00:01:26.453
Quakers and Dickinson's
00:01:26.493 --> 00:01:28.555
name kept coming up and
00:01:29.296 --> 00:01:30.037
there was nothing but
00:01:30.076 --> 00:01:32.218
confusion when I tried to find more.
00:01:32.259 --> 00:01:33.379
The historians really didn't
00:01:33.400 --> 00:01:34.680
seem to know what to make of him.
00:01:35.561 --> 00:01:38.243
And as I got to sort of
00:01:38.403 --> 00:01:39.545
understand him a little bit,
00:01:39.564 --> 00:01:42.686
I think I was able to
00:01:42.727 --> 00:01:43.707
understand him because I
00:01:43.727 --> 00:01:45.730
had gone to a Quaker college
00:01:46.787 --> 00:01:49.468
And as I learned about Quakerism,
00:01:50.048 --> 00:01:51.629
I found it quite appealing,
00:01:51.709 --> 00:01:53.370
but I myself did not want
00:01:53.390 --> 00:01:54.329
to become a Quaker.
00:01:54.549 --> 00:01:57.671
And that seemed to me
00:01:57.730 --> 00:01:59.512
exactly what was going on with Dickinson,
00:01:59.572 --> 00:02:02.033
that there was a lot of questions.
00:02:02.052 --> 00:02:03.513
Well, was Dickinson a Quaker?
00:02:03.533 --> 00:02:04.573
Was he not a Quaker?
00:02:04.914 --> 00:02:06.353
And why did he do what he did,
00:02:06.433 --> 00:02:08.835
namely lead the resistance to Britain,
00:02:08.875 --> 00:02:11.316
but then not vote on or
00:02:11.355 --> 00:02:12.776
sign the Declaration of Independence?
00:02:13.236 --> 00:02:14.336
And so when I looked at him,
00:02:14.956 --> 00:02:17.258
it just resonated because I'm like, well,
00:02:17.318 --> 00:02:17.518
you know,
00:02:17.538 --> 00:02:19.778
it's very clear that he was what
00:02:19.818 --> 00:02:20.739
Quakers call a fellow
00:02:20.778 --> 00:02:23.118
traveler and really
00:02:23.158 --> 00:02:24.319
sympathetic with a lot of
00:02:24.379 --> 00:02:27.760
Quaker causes and concerns and interests.
00:02:28.140 --> 00:02:29.420
But he himself never wanted
00:02:29.441 --> 00:02:30.300
to become a Quaker.
00:02:30.881 --> 00:02:32.021
And that just made all the
00:02:32.042 --> 00:02:33.141
sense in the world to me.
00:02:33.342 --> 00:02:35.241
And so I found him
00:02:35.902 --> 00:02:40.283
relatively easy to explain after, like,
00:02:40.324 --> 00:02:41.443
I made that connection.
00:02:43.438 --> 00:02:45.802
interesting and I I was just
00:02:45.823 --> 00:02:46.844
by the way reading some of
00:02:46.884 --> 00:02:48.167
his letters in preparation
00:02:48.187 --> 00:02:49.187
for this since he goes back
00:02:49.228 --> 00:02:50.050
and forth between
00:02:50.090 --> 00:02:51.252
addressing someone as thou
00:02:51.271 --> 00:02:52.894
and you that is he's using
00:02:52.954 --> 00:02:54.175
sometimes a quaker formula
00:02:54.216 --> 00:02:55.639
and sometimes he isn't which
00:02:56.525 --> 00:02:57.145
So yeah,
00:02:58.265 --> 00:03:01.866
the later in life we go in
00:03:01.887 --> 00:03:03.647
Dickinson's biography,
00:03:04.427 --> 00:03:05.907
the more Quakerly he became.
00:03:06.549 --> 00:03:08.269
And so early,
00:03:08.969 --> 00:03:09.990
when you're seeing letters
00:03:10.590 --> 00:03:13.350
where he is addressing someone as you,
00:03:14.170 --> 00:03:16.072
which is the plural formal
00:03:16.092 --> 00:03:17.893
that we use today for the
00:03:17.953 --> 00:03:19.212
individual singular,
00:03:20.794 --> 00:03:22.074
that was either early in
00:03:22.133 --> 00:03:23.074
his life or when he was
00:03:23.094 --> 00:03:24.055
sort of transitioning
00:03:24.514 --> 00:03:27.036
from the kind of regular
00:03:27.075 --> 00:03:28.256
speech to what we call the
00:03:28.276 --> 00:03:29.296
Quaker plain speech.
00:03:29.597 --> 00:03:30.556
But then later in life,
00:03:31.937 --> 00:03:35.038
his letters are all using thee and thou.
00:03:35.558 --> 00:03:37.360
And that's because he became
00:03:37.439 --> 00:03:39.080
just much more sort of
00:03:39.159 --> 00:03:41.860
Quakerly in his everyday
00:03:42.002 --> 00:03:43.021
life and his demeanor.
00:03:43.981 --> 00:03:46.962
his clothing, his speech, everything.
00:03:47.483 --> 00:03:48.383
But yeah,
00:03:48.403 --> 00:03:50.544
there was a period sort of in the
00:03:50.625 --> 00:03:51.444
seventeen eighties where he
00:03:51.504 --> 00:03:53.125
kind of was sort of
00:03:53.145 --> 00:03:54.466
switching back and forth a little bit.
00:03:54.765 --> 00:03:55.225
Interesting.
00:03:55.325 --> 00:03:55.626
Interesting.
00:03:56.227 --> 00:03:59.848
And he also writes probably
00:03:59.888 --> 00:04:01.548
the most important American
00:04:01.587 --> 00:04:03.468
political track before the revolution,
00:04:03.489 --> 00:04:04.530
The Farmers Letters.
00:04:04.569 --> 00:04:05.710
Can we talk a little bit about
00:04:06.384 --> 00:04:07.824
that because it's something
00:04:07.844 --> 00:04:09.126
that remains part of the
00:04:09.165 --> 00:04:11.825
canon into the early nineteenth century.
00:04:11.846 --> 00:04:12.806
The farmer's letters is
00:04:12.885 --> 00:04:14.187
really a staple of American
00:04:14.227 --> 00:04:15.067
political thought.
00:04:16.567 --> 00:04:16.867
Yes.
00:04:17.747 --> 00:04:18.766
So, yeah, I mean,
00:04:18.826 --> 00:04:20.468
he had taken a lead in the
00:04:20.507 --> 00:04:21.608
Stamp Act resistance.
00:04:22.447 --> 00:04:24.427
And then after that,
00:04:25.629 --> 00:04:27.689
the parliament passed the
00:04:27.728 --> 00:04:30.569
Declaratory Act and the Townsend Act.
00:04:31.149 --> 00:04:31.430
And
00:04:32.670 --> 00:04:33.509
Dickinson was sort of
00:04:33.591 --> 00:04:34.951
waiting for somebody else
00:04:35.011 --> 00:04:37.471
to start protesting the
00:04:37.492 --> 00:04:40.552
Townsend acts and people weren't, they,
00:04:40.612 --> 00:04:40.692
they,
00:04:40.773 --> 00:04:41.973
all the people who were so upset
00:04:41.994 --> 00:04:43.634
about the stamp act were
00:04:43.673 --> 00:04:45.235
not upset about the Townsend acts.
00:04:45.295 --> 00:04:46.915
And so he, he kind of waited.
00:04:46.975 --> 00:04:48.255
And then when nobody stepped forward,
00:04:48.456 --> 00:04:49.915
he decided he had to do it.
00:04:50.276 --> 00:04:52.697
And so these letters he wrote, um,
00:04:52.776 --> 00:04:55.819
under the pen name of farmer and, uh, he,
00:04:56.119 --> 00:04:56.238
um, uh,
00:04:57.579 --> 00:04:59.721
basically was taking it upon
00:04:59.761 --> 00:05:02.002
himself to educate
00:05:02.062 --> 00:05:04.843
Americans about their
00:05:04.923 --> 00:05:06.185
rights and about how to
00:05:06.264 --> 00:05:09.086
resist encroachment on them
00:05:09.206 --> 00:05:10.307
or oppression by the
00:05:10.326 --> 00:05:11.367
government peacefully,
00:05:12.228 --> 00:05:14.509
and to instruct Americans in
00:05:15.750 --> 00:05:17.050
the fact that they were
00:05:17.531 --> 00:05:19.333
American and that they had
00:05:19.353 --> 00:05:20.673
an identity that was
00:05:20.994 --> 00:05:22.355
distinct from Britain.
00:05:22.915 --> 00:05:24.016
And so,
00:05:25.276 --> 00:05:26.718
and he was very specifically
00:05:26.858 --> 00:05:28.879
addressing the ordinary people,
00:05:28.920 --> 00:05:30.901
working people and, you know,
00:05:30.940 --> 00:05:33.843
people who may not even have, you know,
00:05:33.862 --> 00:05:34.903
been able to read.
00:05:35.483 --> 00:05:37.925
And so he's sort of really
00:05:37.966 --> 00:05:40.067
trying to just sort of
00:05:41.636 --> 00:05:43.016
garner a sense of American
00:05:43.076 --> 00:05:45.439
identity and unity and
00:05:45.519 --> 00:05:47.081
peaceful resistance in
00:05:47.161 --> 00:05:48.942
order to defend their rights.
00:05:49.822 --> 00:05:53.387
And this persona of a farmer,
00:05:55.028 --> 00:05:55.928
I've seen people sort of
00:05:56.168 --> 00:05:57.730
criticizing Dickinson saying, oh, well,
00:05:57.771 --> 00:05:59.012
he wasn't a farmer at all.
00:05:59.692 --> 00:06:01.014
He was a lawyer and he lived
00:06:01.053 --> 00:06:01.874
in Philadelphia.
00:06:01.894 --> 00:06:03.696
And well, that is true,
00:06:04.396 --> 00:06:05.677
but he also had a
00:06:05.718 --> 00:06:07.720
plantation down in Kent County,
00:06:08.079 --> 00:06:09.721
um in what is now delaware
00:06:09.761 --> 00:06:10.802
when at the time that was
00:06:10.841 --> 00:06:12.663
part of pennsylvania and
00:06:13.062 --> 00:06:14.463
and so um he was
00:06:14.524 --> 00:06:16.024
technically a gentleman
00:06:16.045 --> 00:06:17.665
farmer nobody nobody
00:06:17.706 --> 00:06:19.206
mistook him for you know
00:06:19.226 --> 00:06:19.987
someone who was walking
00:06:20.028 --> 00:06:21.309
behind a plow with dirt
00:06:21.369 --> 00:06:23.009
under his fingernails um
00:06:23.029 --> 00:06:24.850
but this this persona was
00:06:25.211 --> 00:06:27.153
someone who the um the
00:06:27.192 --> 00:06:28.733
upper sorts the elite could
00:06:28.774 --> 00:06:30.014
trust because he he
00:06:30.035 --> 00:06:31.175
described himself as having
00:06:31.495 --> 00:06:32.836
you know a library and an
00:06:32.937 --> 00:06:35.218
education and uh and uh and
00:06:36.079 --> 00:06:37.660
really you know he had some money
00:06:38.920 --> 00:06:41.423
And so the elite could trust
00:06:41.483 --> 00:06:43.064
him as one of their own,
00:06:43.404 --> 00:06:45.065
but then also he was doing
00:06:45.346 --> 00:06:47.127
the duty that a gentleman
00:06:47.187 --> 00:06:49.589
has to the lower sorts of people,
00:06:49.629 --> 00:06:51.110
which is to sort of,
00:06:51.891 --> 00:06:53.432
the word was to condescend to them,
00:06:53.452 --> 00:06:55.093
which was a very positive thing.
00:06:55.113 --> 00:06:56.235
A gentleman was supposed to
00:06:56.336 --> 00:06:59.158
lower himself to speak
00:06:59.557 --> 00:07:01.379
with his inferiors.
00:07:01.738 --> 00:07:03.238
And so Dickinson was doing that.
00:07:04.000 --> 00:07:05.439
And so the ordinary people
00:07:05.480 --> 00:07:06.581
trusted him as well.
00:07:06.980 --> 00:07:08.880
And so these letters caught
00:07:09.021 --> 00:07:12.083
on like nothing before and
00:07:12.262 --> 00:07:13.543
really launched Dickinson
00:07:13.622 --> 00:07:15.824
into international celebrity.
00:07:17.764 --> 00:07:19.548
So he wasn't pretending to
00:07:19.588 --> 00:07:20.689
be a man of the people.
00:07:20.769 --> 00:07:22.732
He was acting in a certain station.
00:07:22.771 --> 00:07:23.173
And again,
00:07:23.213 --> 00:07:24.454
farmers were also seen as
00:07:24.935 --> 00:07:26.036
uncorruptible because they
00:07:26.218 --> 00:07:27.358
owned something and they
00:07:27.399 --> 00:07:28.701
had a certain stake in this
00:07:28.740 --> 00:07:29.903
and they were disinterested,
00:07:29.963 --> 00:07:31.144
I think would be another word.
00:07:32.300 --> 00:07:34.783
That is the key word, disinterested.
00:07:35.124 --> 00:07:35.803
So of course,
00:07:35.824 --> 00:07:37.264
that doesn't mean uninterested.
00:07:37.305 --> 00:07:38.427
It means impartial.
00:07:39.447 --> 00:07:40.307
There's a lot of confusion
00:07:40.327 --> 00:07:41.189
today about that word.
00:07:41.829 --> 00:07:42.930
People use it synonymously
00:07:42.971 --> 00:07:43.831
with uninterested.
00:07:43.930 --> 00:07:45.452
But disinterested meant that
00:07:45.492 --> 00:07:46.314
he was impartial.
00:07:46.653 --> 00:07:47.113
And yes,
00:07:47.375 --> 00:07:49.716
it was because he was tied to the land.
00:07:49.776 --> 00:07:50.718
He was independent.
00:07:51.237 --> 00:07:54.360
And so yes, that's exactly right.
00:07:54.641 --> 00:07:55.822
He was not pretending to be
00:07:55.841 --> 00:07:56.583
a man of the people.
00:07:56.882 --> 00:07:59.425
His Quaker beliefs meant
00:07:59.464 --> 00:08:02.206
that he actually truly believed that all,
00:08:02.648 --> 00:08:03.348
not just men,
00:08:03.468 --> 00:08:05.189
all people were created equal.
00:08:05.649 --> 00:08:07.372
And so he believed that
00:08:07.432 --> 00:08:11.035
there was that of God in every person.
00:08:11.334 --> 00:08:12.435
And so every person,
00:08:12.696 --> 00:08:14.297
and he says it in his opening letter,
00:08:14.958 --> 00:08:16.478
it doesn't matter how poor
00:08:16.899 --> 00:08:17.860
or weak you may be,
00:08:18.781 --> 00:08:20.322
you should speak up and you
00:08:20.341 --> 00:08:22.184
should engage because you
00:08:22.244 --> 00:08:23.245
never know what kind of
00:08:23.285 --> 00:08:24.384
difference it might make.
00:08:25.269 --> 00:08:26.189
Interesting.
00:08:26.209 --> 00:08:27.630
We're talking with Jane Calvert,
00:08:27.790 --> 00:08:29.411
author of Penman of the Founding,
00:08:29.511 --> 00:08:31.351
a biography of John Dickinson,
00:08:31.391 --> 00:08:33.091
and also the director and
00:08:33.111 --> 00:08:34.133
chief editor of the John
00:08:34.173 --> 00:08:35.533
Dickinson Writing Project,
00:08:35.552 --> 00:08:37.394
talking about John Dickinson.
00:08:37.673 --> 00:08:39.794
Had he spent time in Great Britain before
00:08:42.095 --> 00:08:43.054
Yes, he did.
00:08:43.115 --> 00:08:43.495
In fact,
00:08:43.715 --> 00:08:47.255
he went for his legal training to London.
00:08:47.416 --> 00:08:48.496
He was at the Middle Temple,
00:08:48.537 --> 00:08:50.636
which is one of the inns of
00:08:50.677 --> 00:08:52.437
court in London.
00:08:52.677 --> 00:08:54.018
And so he was there from
00:08:54.437 --> 00:08:56.457
late-seventeen-fifty-three
00:08:56.557 --> 00:08:58.639
to early-seventeen-fifty-seven.
00:08:58.658 --> 00:09:00.418
So he was there for three years.
00:09:00.899 --> 00:09:02.299
And he went over with the
00:09:02.340 --> 00:09:03.460
intent of just staying a
00:09:03.500 --> 00:09:05.360
couple of years and becoming a solicitor.
00:09:05.860 --> 00:09:09.061
But he was so good at what
00:09:09.100 --> 00:09:10.101
he was doing that he caught
00:09:10.142 --> 00:09:11.201
the attention of
00:09:11.562 --> 00:09:12.241
the treasurer,
00:09:12.922 --> 00:09:15.503
the head of the Middle Temple,
00:09:15.962 --> 00:09:17.504
and he ended up staying an
00:09:17.563 --> 00:09:20.104
extra year and becoming a barrister.
00:09:20.605 --> 00:09:21.985
There was a very high achievement.
00:09:22.625 --> 00:09:24.426
While he was in London,
00:09:24.446 --> 00:09:27.005
and this is very different
00:09:27.846 --> 00:09:28.687
compared to someone like
00:09:28.947 --> 00:09:29.606
Benjamin Franklin,
00:09:30.366 --> 00:09:31.748
when Dickinson was in London,
00:09:32.288 --> 00:09:33.908
he really started
00:09:33.988 --> 00:09:35.729
identifying as an American
00:09:36.009 --> 00:09:38.129
and missing his homeland.
00:09:38.309 --> 00:09:39.330
Interesting.
00:09:39.789 --> 00:09:42.230
And he really started
00:09:42.490 --> 00:09:44.750
thinking how proud he was
00:09:44.791 --> 00:09:46.291
to be an American and that
00:09:46.331 --> 00:09:50.371
it meant that he and the
00:09:50.432 --> 00:09:52.532
other Americans he was associated with,
00:09:54.231 --> 00:09:55.753
the distinguishing features
00:09:55.873 --> 00:09:56.952
of their American identity
00:09:56.993 --> 00:09:59.972
was that they were sober and industrious.
00:10:00.453 --> 00:10:02.153
And in other words, virtuous.
00:10:02.614 --> 00:10:04.854
And so, yes, it was, I think,
00:10:04.894 --> 00:10:06.475
a really important
00:10:07.195 --> 00:10:08.914
formative moment in his life.
00:10:09.315 --> 00:10:10.216
And whereas, you know,
00:10:10.296 --> 00:10:13.058
other founders like like Franklin,
00:10:13.678 --> 00:10:13.860
you know,
00:10:13.879 --> 00:10:15.480
went over and wanted to just
00:10:15.561 --> 00:10:18.884
stay and more or less become, you know,
00:10:18.924 --> 00:10:20.466
British and sit in parliament.
00:10:20.485 --> 00:10:20.566
Yeah.
00:10:20.745 --> 00:10:21.366
Yeah.
00:10:21.706 --> 00:10:23.589
Like Franklin was there for about fifteen,
00:10:23.649 --> 00:10:25.291
seventeen years and he has
00:10:25.311 --> 00:10:26.591
a brief respite back.
00:10:26.832 --> 00:10:27.874
But you get the feeling this
00:10:27.913 --> 00:10:28.975
is where he wants to stay.
00:10:29.034 --> 00:10:29.855
This is really where his
00:10:29.895 --> 00:10:31.317
life is at the center of things.
00:10:31.961 --> 00:10:32.341
Indeed,
00:10:32.801 --> 00:10:34.761
he would not have come back and
00:10:34.802 --> 00:10:35.802
joined the American cause
00:10:36.082 --> 00:10:37.783
had he not been humiliated
00:10:38.504 --> 00:10:41.065
in his goal to get a seat in Parliament.
00:10:41.365 --> 00:10:42.525
So really, you know,
00:10:42.586 --> 00:10:43.525
his interest in becoming a
00:10:43.586 --> 00:10:46.206
patriot was a vindictive one to sort of,
00:10:46.326 --> 00:10:48.888
you know, stick it to the British Empire.
00:10:48.967 --> 00:10:50.369
And Dickinson and Franklin
00:10:50.428 --> 00:10:51.950
don't really get along very
00:10:52.009 --> 00:10:52.730
well politically.
00:10:53.666 --> 00:10:54.947
No, no, not at all.
00:10:54.986 --> 00:10:56.508
They were at odds with one
00:10:56.548 --> 00:10:58.568
another on several major issues.
00:11:00.049 --> 00:11:00.669
First of all,
00:11:01.409 --> 00:11:03.130
Dickinson was a defense
00:11:03.150 --> 00:11:06.092
attorney for Reverend William Smith,
00:11:06.452 --> 00:11:08.894
who was put on trial for libel.
00:11:08.913 --> 00:11:12.275
He was tried for libel of
00:11:12.336 --> 00:11:13.476
the Pennsylvania Assembly
00:11:13.537 --> 00:11:14.977
by the Pennsylvania Assembly.
00:11:15.298 --> 00:11:16.678
And Dickinson defended him.
00:11:16.958 --> 00:11:18.980
And Franklin was on the other side of that,
00:11:19.500 --> 00:11:21.660
trying to get, you know,
00:11:21.701 --> 00:11:22.461
to sort of impeach
00:11:23.322 --> 00:11:26.625
Smith's character and have him imprisoned.
00:11:26.725 --> 00:11:29.749
And then Franklin and Joseph
00:11:29.788 --> 00:11:31.691
Galloway in seventeen
00:11:31.730 --> 00:11:33.893
sixty-four tried to abolish
00:11:34.254 --> 00:11:35.794
the Quakers' seventeen oh
00:11:36.034 --> 00:11:37.996
one constitution for
00:11:38.017 --> 00:11:39.839
Pennsylvania and Dickinson
00:11:40.099 --> 00:11:41.520
fought against that because
00:11:42.701 --> 00:11:43.763
It that that constitution
00:11:43.822 --> 00:11:45.464
was it provided liberty of
00:11:45.524 --> 00:11:46.985
conscience for everybody in
00:11:47.024 --> 00:11:48.866
Pennsylvania and something
00:11:48.927 --> 00:11:49.986
Franklin wouldn't really
00:11:50.148 --> 00:11:51.268
care much about because he
00:11:51.308 --> 00:11:54.230
himself was not a religious dissenter.
00:11:54.870 --> 00:11:56.292
And anyway, so, yes,
00:11:57.013 --> 00:11:58.474
I think that Dickinson
00:11:58.594 --> 00:11:59.875
Dickinson was a very.
00:12:01.394 --> 00:12:02.375
He was a straight shooter.
00:12:02.754 --> 00:12:04.756
He was extraordinarily
00:12:04.797 --> 00:12:06.977
virtuous and self-sacrificing.
00:12:07.339 --> 00:12:09.841
And he saw Franklin as someone who would,
00:12:09.860 --> 00:12:11.721
you know,
00:12:11.741 --> 00:12:14.384
try to profit from his political
00:12:14.464 --> 00:12:17.706
offices and someone who was
00:12:17.787 --> 00:12:18.788
not to be trusted.
00:12:19.207 --> 00:12:22.791
And so, no, the two did not,
00:12:23.010 --> 00:12:24.091
they had no personal
00:12:24.111 --> 00:12:25.212
relationship that I've been
00:12:25.253 --> 00:12:26.053
able to discern.
00:12:26.647 --> 00:12:27.368
That's interesting.
00:12:28.089 --> 00:12:28.649
Just quickly,
00:12:28.769 --> 00:12:29.971
is there a difference in
00:12:30.032 --> 00:12:31.433
America between solicitors
00:12:31.474 --> 00:12:31.994
and barristers?
00:12:32.054 --> 00:12:33.476
I mean, in England, you do have that.
00:12:33.697 --> 00:12:34.697
So he comes back.
00:12:34.798 --> 00:12:36.461
So is there a distinction here?
00:12:37.230 --> 00:12:38.251
There isn't much of one
00:12:38.292 --> 00:12:40.133
because there were fewer
00:12:40.173 --> 00:12:43.556
lawyers and so basically
00:12:43.655 --> 00:12:44.937
lawyers had to sort of take
00:12:45.076 --> 00:12:47.438
on all roles and all duties
00:12:47.839 --> 00:12:49.299
and they had to sort of do
00:12:49.341 --> 00:12:52.163
the kind of like paperwork
00:12:52.202 --> 00:12:53.384
behind the scenes and they
00:12:53.443 --> 00:12:55.926
also had to argue in court.
00:12:56.365 --> 00:12:57.626
And so, you know,
00:12:57.846 --> 00:12:59.187
they took every kind of case.
00:12:59.207 --> 00:13:00.349
They didn't specialize.
00:13:01.169 --> 00:13:01.549
So, you know,
00:13:01.570 --> 00:13:02.811
they took everything from sort of,
00:13:03.191 --> 00:13:03.471
you know,
00:13:04.971 --> 00:13:08.033
trying to collect small debts, to,
00:13:08.052 --> 00:13:13.014
you know, trespasses, to murder, you know,
00:13:13.094 --> 00:13:15.053
criminal trials, you know,
00:13:15.134 --> 00:13:16.254
just what they did everything.
00:13:16.274 --> 00:13:16.975
So, yeah.
00:13:17.235 --> 00:13:17.355
Okay.
00:13:18.735 --> 00:13:19.075
Now he's,
00:13:19.315 --> 00:13:20.315
so he comes back and he's
00:13:21.375 --> 00:13:22.696
essentially going to set up
00:13:22.716 --> 00:13:24.576
a successful law practice.
00:13:24.755 --> 00:13:27.956
What draws him into becoming a politician?
00:13:29.298 --> 00:13:29.559
Well,
00:13:29.700 --> 00:13:31.922
it was kind of something that if you
00:13:31.981 --> 00:13:34.184
were a wealthy gentleman,
00:13:34.504 --> 00:13:36.307
it was just understood that
00:13:36.726 --> 00:13:38.669
you would serve in public office.
00:13:38.690 --> 00:13:39.870
It was part of the duties of
00:13:39.931 --> 00:13:40.672
being a gentleman,
00:13:40.971 --> 00:13:43.073
that you were there to lead
00:13:43.495 --> 00:13:47.899
and to basically –
00:13:47.318 --> 00:13:49.461
Yeah, to protect the lower sort.
00:13:49.941 --> 00:13:52.803
And so it was just a part of
00:13:52.823 --> 00:13:54.345
what Dickinson assumed he would do.
00:13:54.365 --> 00:13:57.067
And so he entered politics
00:13:57.147 --> 00:13:58.327
in seventeen fifty nine
00:13:58.368 --> 00:14:00.710
when he was elected to the
00:14:00.769 --> 00:14:02.451
legislature of the three
00:14:02.471 --> 00:14:03.912
lower counties of Pennsylvania,
00:14:03.932 --> 00:14:04.952
which is now Delaware.
00:14:05.113 --> 00:14:05.774
It had its separate
00:14:05.813 --> 00:14:09.277
legislature from Pennsylvania.
00:14:09.356 --> 00:14:10.236
And then he essentially
00:14:10.256 --> 00:14:11.739
spends the rest of his life
00:14:11.818 --> 00:14:13.620
almost as a public servant
00:14:13.639 --> 00:14:14.600
then in that sense.
00:14:15.296 --> 00:14:16.096
Yeah, absolutely.
00:14:16.115 --> 00:14:16.376
I mean,
00:14:16.437 --> 00:14:18.957
his last public office that he held
00:14:18.977 --> 00:14:20.457
was in seventeen ninety three.
00:14:20.818 --> 00:14:22.198
That doesn't mean he
00:14:22.239 --> 00:14:23.919
abstained from politics by any means,
00:14:24.240 --> 00:14:27.140
but he was not continuously in office.
00:14:27.160 --> 00:14:29.101
There were a few years here
00:14:29.142 --> 00:14:30.263
and there where he did not
00:14:30.302 --> 00:14:31.823
hold public office, but more or less,
00:14:32.203 --> 00:14:33.464
more or less continuously.
00:14:33.484 --> 00:14:35.784
And even if he wasn't
00:14:35.904 --> 00:14:37.206
actually holding office,
00:14:37.525 --> 00:14:38.947
he was usually writing
00:14:40.086 --> 00:14:41.868
about politics and engaging
00:14:41.927 --> 00:14:43.009
in one way or the other.
00:14:44.378 --> 00:14:45.778
We're talking with Jane Calvert,
00:14:45.899 --> 00:14:47.340
author of Penman of the Founding,
00:14:47.379 --> 00:14:48.620
a biography of John
00:14:48.660 --> 00:14:49.802
Dickinson and also the
00:14:49.881 --> 00:14:51.121
editor of the John
00:14:51.162 --> 00:14:52.503
Dickinson Writings Project.
00:14:52.743 --> 00:14:54.083
By the way, I just found this,
00:14:54.664 --> 00:14:55.845
you're mentioning Dickinson
00:14:55.965 --> 00:14:57.385
realizing he's an American
00:14:57.426 --> 00:14:58.466
in the seventeen fifties
00:14:58.506 --> 00:14:59.628
when he is in London.
00:15:00.347 --> 00:15:02.629
And then this probably is
00:15:02.669 --> 00:15:03.870
what draws him into
00:15:03.951 --> 00:15:05.410
supporting this cause and
00:15:05.431 --> 00:15:06.652
being one of the first real
00:15:07.192 --> 00:15:07.852
advocates for this.
00:15:07.873 --> 00:15:10.294
But this is in February of eighteen oh one,
00:15:10.534 --> 00:15:10.774
when
00:15:11.740 --> 00:15:12.880
Congress elected Thomas
00:15:12.921 --> 00:15:14.120
Jefferson president after
00:15:14.140 --> 00:15:15.162
this disputed election.
00:15:15.182 --> 00:15:16.361
He writes this extraordinary
00:15:16.461 --> 00:15:18.221
letter to Jefferson and
00:15:18.241 --> 00:15:20.763
this just leaped out this line,
00:15:21.102 --> 00:15:23.182
perhaps we are the selected
00:15:23.222 --> 00:15:25.043
people upon the earth from
00:15:25.082 --> 00:15:26.302
whom large portions of
00:15:26.363 --> 00:15:27.803
mankind are to learn that
00:15:27.864 --> 00:15:29.004
liberty is really a
00:15:29.083 --> 00:15:31.043
transcendental blessing as
00:15:31.083 --> 00:15:33.365
capable by its enlightened
00:15:33.504 --> 00:15:35.144
energies of calmly
00:15:35.184 --> 00:15:36.625
dissipating its internal
00:15:36.705 --> 00:15:38.586
enemies as of triumphantly
00:15:38.625 --> 00:15:40.725
repelling its foreign foes.
00:15:41.697 --> 00:15:42.740
It's an extraordinary
00:15:42.820 --> 00:15:47.528
statement about the American role in .
00:15:46.808 --> 00:15:51.097
And then Jefferson writes .
00:15:52.414 --> 00:15:55.397
I'll let you go on.
00:15:55.496 --> 00:15:55.797
Yeah, yeah.
00:15:55.836 --> 00:15:57.658
Well, you know, yeah, I just,
00:15:57.677 --> 00:16:00.379
those kinds of wonderful
00:16:00.418 --> 00:16:02.399
passages just abound in
00:16:02.421 --> 00:16:03.681
Dickinson's writing.
00:16:03.701 --> 00:16:07.123
I am continually amazed by
00:16:07.302 --> 00:16:10.245
not just his sort of vision for America,
00:16:10.585 --> 00:16:14.287
but also his prescience in that really,
00:16:14.307 --> 00:16:16.388
I mean, people call him forward-looking.
00:16:16.548 --> 00:16:18.369
I would say he was kind of, you know,
00:16:18.589 --> 00:16:19.250
Quakerly,
00:16:20.190 --> 00:16:21.971
in that how much he cared
00:16:22.331 --> 00:16:25.033
about individual rights, for example,
00:16:25.433 --> 00:16:29.635
and really tried to realize
00:16:30.677 --> 00:16:31.437
the promise of the
00:16:31.477 --> 00:16:32.758
Declaration of Independence.
00:16:32.957 --> 00:16:34.318
And he read the Declaration
00:16:34.339 --> 00:16:36.159
of Independence much more
00:16:36.240 --> 00:16:38.522
as we do today than other
00:16:38.562 --> 00:16:40.082
men of the time.
00:16:42.024 --> 00:16:42.784
And so that's just a
00:16:42.825 --> 00:16:44.426
wonderful passage because
00:16:44.666 --> 00:16:46.768
it really exemplifies
00:16:46.847 --> 00:16:49.048
Dickinson's thoughts about
00:16:49.409 --> 00:16:51.990
liberty and about the role
00:16:52.110 --> 00:16:55.793
of religion in that,
00:16:56.414 --> 00:16:57.875
but also the kind of
00:16:58.176 --> 00:16:59.476
moderate stance he took
00:16:59.537 --> 00:17:04.780
about not being someone who
00:17:05.181 --> 00:17:08.462
believed in violence as a way to achieve
00:17:09.864 --> 00:17:10.744
Liberty for all.
00:17:11.065 --> 00:17:13.047
So, yes, it's a very, very nice passage.
00:17:13.267 --> 00:17:14.728
It really is.
00:17:14.748 --> 00:17:15.949
So what draws him then?
00:17:15.969 --> 00:17:18.290
And so he doesn't sign the declaration,
00:17:18.310 --> 00:17:19.192
but then he's really the
00:17:19.271 --> 00:17:20.413
main author of the Articles
00:17:20.432 --> 00:17:21.193
of Confederation,
00:17:21.213 --> 00:17:23.195
this attempt to hold this union together.
00:17:23.596 --> 00:17:24.416
And then what kind of a role
00:17:24.436 --> 00:17:26.077
does he play during the war itself?
00:17:27.701 --> 00:17:32.305
So Dickinson's authorship of
00:17:32.786 --> 00:17:33.326
the Articles of
00:17:33.385 --> 00:17:35.527
Confederation was really
00:17:35.586 --> 00:17:37.288
kind of the capstone
00:17:37.808 --> 00:17:41.431
feature of his efforts to
00:17:41.511 --> 00:17:44.913
prepare America for the
00:17:44.933 --> 00:17:46.654
Declaration of Independence.
00:17:48.336 --> 00:17:50.317
So he'd spent the ten years prior
00:17:51.565 --> 00:17:53.665
trying to unify Americans
00:17:53.885 --> 00:17:56.288
because he he saw independence coming,
00:17:56.307 --> 00:18:00.509
you know, since seventeen sixty five,
00:18:00.650 --> 00:18:01.029
you know,
00:18:02.030 --> 00:18:04.392
at at least seventeen sixty five.
00:18:04.451 --> 00:18:05.952
He was he was concerned about that.
00:18:06.292 --> 00:18:08.493
And so he did more than any
00:18:08.554 --> 00:18:09.775
other single person to
00:18:09.815 --> 00:18:11.615
prepare America for independence.
00:18:11.915 --> 00:18:12.715
And by that,
00:18:12.816 --> 00:18:16.597
I mean he tried to unify America.
00:18:16.657 --> 00:18:18.499
He did more than really any
00:18:18.538 --> 00:18:19.700
other single person.
00:18:20.000 --> 00:18:23.903
to prepare America militarily,
00:18:24.664 --> 00:18:26.066
including raising a battalion.
00:18:26.247 --> 00:18:27.647
And he at one point had
00:18:27.708 --> 00:18:28.828
control of the entire
00:18:29.250 --> 00:18:30.330
Pennsylvania militia.
00:18:31.392 --> 00:18:34.976
And he just really was
00:18:34.996 --> 00:18:37.038
concerned about America being prepared.
00:18:37.478 --> 00:18:39.219
And so the Articles of Confederation,
00:18:39.239 --> 00:18:39.859
you know,
00:18:40.000 --> 00:18:41.381
there were there were there were
00:18:41.601 --> 00:18:42.862
three key committees that
00:18:42.902 --> 00:18:43.922
were formed in June of
00:18:43.961 --> 00:18:45.123
seventeen seventy six.
00:18:45.624 --> 00:18:46.844
And and Dickinson,
00:18:48.005 --> 00:18:49.086
one was the committee to
00:18:49.105 --> 00:18:51.346
write the declaration, which Dickinson,
00:18:51.386 --> 00:18:51.647
of course,
00:18:51.667 --> 00:18:53.148
was not on because he was not
00:18:53.189 --> 00:18:54.189
in favor of declaring
00:18:54.229 --> 00:18:55.289
independence at that time.
00:18:55.953 --> 00:18:57.174
And then there was the
00:18:57.194 --> 00:19:00.297
committee to write a model
00:19:00.356 --> 00:19:01.657
treaty to be used for
00:19:01.678 --> 00:19:02.818
American foreign policy.
00:19:02.919 --> 00:19:03.598
He was on that one.
00:19:03.919 --> 00:19:04.859
And he was on the committee
00:19:04.940 --> 00:19:08.241
to draft the Articles of Confederation,
00:19:08.321 --> 00:19:09.462
America's First Constitution.
00:19:09.542 --> 00:19:10.983
And then he did draft that
00:19:11.564 --> 00:19:12.444
single-handedly.
00:19:13.125 --> 00:19:18.449
And so then he hoped that
00:19:18.469 --> 00:19:19.490
America would be prepared.
00:19:19.849 --> 00:19:20.549
But he still...
00:19:21.590 --> 00:19:23.271
refused to vote on or sign
00:19:23.291 --> 00:19:23.852
the Declaration of
00:19:23.892 --> 00:19:25.212
Independence because in the first place,
00:19:26.173 --> 00:19:27.294
he knew it was going to pass.
00:19:28.394 --> 00:19:30.016
And if it was going to pass,
00:19:30.135 --> 00:19:30.856
he wanted it to be
00:19:30.936 --> 00:19:32.497
unanimous so that the world
00:19:32.538 --> 00:19:33.978
would know that we were united,
00:19:34.038 --> 00:19:35.638
even though in truth we were not.
00:19:37.059 --> 00:19:38.721
And then he didn't vote on
00:19:38.781 --> 00:19:40.202
it because that would have, I mean, yes,
00:19:40.563 --> 00:19:41.344
he didn't vote on it
00:19:41.364 --> 00:19:42.505
because he wanted to be unanimous.
00:19:42.585 --> 00:19:43.965
And then he didn't sign it because,
00:19:44.006 --> 00:19:44.326
of course,
00:19:44.946 --> 00:19:45.587
that would have been
00:19:45.948 --> 00:19:47.209
disingenuous to sign
00:19:47.249 --> 00:19:48.931
something he hadn't voted for.
00:19:50.092 --> 00:19:51.031
And then,
00:19:52.973 --> 00:19:54.915
but he was fully committed to
00:19:54.955 --> 00:19:56.436
supporting the American
00:19:56.477 --> 00:19:59.339
cause with everything that he had.
00:19:59.700 --> 00:20:00.701
So within days,
00:20:01.101 --> 00:20:02.122
of the passage of the
00:20:02.142 --> 00:20:03.222
Declaration of Independence,
00:20:03.563 --> 00:20:05.344
he then joined the militia
00:20:05.364 --> 00:20:06.924
that he had founded and he
00:20:06.944 --> 00:20:07.965
was deployed to the New
00:20:08.006 --> 00:20:10.027
Jersey front to meet the British.
00:20:10.587 --> 00:20:13.730
And then fast forward to
00:20:13.769 --> 00:20:15.451
seventeen seventy seven.
00:20:15.590 --> 00:20:17.011
And he enlisted in the
00:20:17.051 --> 00:20:18.452
Delaware militia as a private,
00:20:18.493 --> 00:20:19.634
which is something no other
00:20:19.673 --> 00:20:20.454
gentleman did.
00:20:21.315 --> 00:20:24.056
And then he was actually
00:20:24.076 --> 00:20:25.896
then the commander in chief
00:20:26.076 --> 00:20:28.157
of two separate states,
00:20:28.198 --> 00:20:29.798
first Delaware and then Pennsylvania.
00:20:30.239 --> 00:20:33.519
And so he actually had a
00:20:33.779 --> 00:20:35.580
broader and more varied
00:20:35.661 --> 00:20:37.240
military career than even
00:20:37.280 --> 00:20:37.922
George Washington.
00:20:37.942 --> 00:20:39.122
Right, interesting, interesting.
00:20:39.241 --> 00:20:40.103
Now,
00:20:40.123 --> 00:20:42.242
you said that he read the Declaration
00:20:42.344 --> 00:20:45.005
more the way we do.
00:20:45.325 --> 00:20:46.404
Can we talk a little bit
00:20:46.464 --> 00:20:47.566
more about how he
00:20:47.605 --> 00:20:48.445
interprets it and what
00:20:48.465 --> 00:20:49.685
importance that has to his
00:20:49.727 --> 00:20:50.767
vision of America?
00:20:51.808 --> 00:20:53.049
Right.
00:20:53.069 --> 00:20:55.750
There are two very obvious ways.
00:20:56.691 --> 00:20:56.990
First,
00:20:57.411 --> 00:20:59.251
in his draft of the Articles of
00:20:59.311 --> 00:20:59.992
Confederation,
00:21:00.353 --> 00:21:04.974
he included something novel for the time.
00:21:05.035 --> 00:21:06.715
He included an extensive
00:21:06.776 --> 00:21:08.195
religious liberty clause.
00:21:08.615 --> 00:21:10.737
I should say it's novel for America.
00:21:10.777 --> 00:21:12.417
It was not novel for Pennsylvania.
00:21:12.458 --> 00:21:12.817
In fact,
00:21:12.877 --> 00:21:15.839
he copied the language from the
00:21:15.880 --> 00:21:16.380
Pennsylvania,
00:21:16.960 --> 00:21:18.500
one constitution almost
00:21:18.540 --> 00:21:20.342
verbatim into the Articles
00:21:20.382 --> 00:21:21.162
of Confederation.
00:21:21.541 --> 00:21:24.042
But the one really critical
00:21:24.083 --> 00:21:24.963
change he made in the
00:21:25.003 --> 00:21:26.724
language was to use gender
00:21:26.765 --> 00:21:29.586
inclusive language to give women,
00:21:30.266 --> 00:21:32.086
to protect women's religious liberty.
00:21:32.346 --> 00:21:33.228
But more than that,
00:21:34.508 --> 00:21:35.689
he said that they should be
00:21:36.229 --> 00:21:37.769
free to practice their religion.
00:21:37.789 --> 00:21:39.671
And he was thinking of
00:21:39.750 --> 00:21:43.853
Quaker women like his wife and his mother,
00:21:44.673 --> 00:21:45.753
because Quaker women were
00:21:45.773 --> 00:21:48.234
the only women who were
00:21:48.295 --> 00:21:50.096
allowed and encouraged to preach.
00:21:50.435 --> 00:21:51.758
right um and so they were
00:21:51.798 --> 00:21:53.519
ministers so when dickinson
00:21:53.559 --> 00:21:54.681
wrote that women should be
00:21:54.721 --> 00:21:56.482
able to practice their
00:21:56.522 --> 00:21:57.644
religion that was
00:21:57.684 --> 00:22:00.488
effectively trying to
00:22:00.528 --> 00:22:02.450
protect their um their
00:22:02.670 --> 00:22:06.535
their freedom of public speech so that
00:22:07.336 --> 00:22:08.676
I believe is the most
00:22:08.757 --> 00:22:11.119
radical moment of the revolution.
00:22:11.400 --> 00:22:12.560
And of course the whole
00:22:12.601 --> 00:22:15.123
clause was excised from the
00:22:15.163 --> 00:22:16.364
Articles of Confederation
00:22:16.443 --> 00:22:17.904
and just wiped out.
00:22:19.586 --> 00:22:21.347
And then the other thing
00:22:21.367 --> 00:22:23.210
that Dickinson did that again,
00:22:23.289 --> 00:22:26.031
no other major founder did was he
00:22:27.605 --> 00:22:29.646
had long disliked slavery.
00:22:30.307 --> 00:22:32.210
And so in seventeen seventy seven,
00:22:32.390 --> 00:22:34.112
he began the process of
00:22:34.432 --> 00:22:36.194
manumitting or freeing the
00:22:36.234 --> 00:22:37.615
people he enslaved.
00:22:37.655 --> 00:22:38.938
He and he had inherited
00:22:38.998 --> 00:22:41.701
slaves from his father and
00:22:42.721 --> 00:22:44.324
and he had started sort of
00:22:44.344 --> 00:22:45.565
speaking out publicly
00:22:45.625 --> 00:22:47.186
against slavery in the
00:22:47.247 --> 00:22:48.489
early seventeen seventies.
00:22:48.868 --> 00:22:50.631
But then he wrote his first
00:22:50.871 --> 00:22:53.053
manumission deed to free
00:22:53.073 --> 00:22:54.453
them conditionally in
00:22:54.493 --> 00:22:55.474
seventeen seventy seven.
00:22:55.996 --> 00:22:59.439
And but then he he he he was
00:22:59.479 --> 00:23:01.339
trying to sort of, as he as he put it,
00:23:01.621 --> 00:23:04.103
make the state of slavery easy on them.
00:23:04.403 --> 00:23:05.544
But then he realized that
00:23:05.564 --> 00:23:07.786
that was just a lie that he
00:23:07.806 --> 00:23:08.747
was telling himself.
00:23:09.207 --> 00:23:10.848
And there was really no
00:23:11.009 --> 00:23:12.711
other alternative than to
00:23:13.131 --> 00:23:14.711
free them unconditionally.
00:23:14.771 --> 00:23:15.093
So he.
00:23:15.532 --> 00:23:16.374
He freed some of them
00:23:16.453 --> 00:23:17.494
unconditionally in
00:23:17.555 --> 00:23:18.715
seventeen eighty one and
00:23:18.756 --> 00:23:20.738
the remainder he freed in
00:23:20.837 --> 00:23:22.219
seventeen eighty six.
00:23:22.318 --> 00:23:24.761
And then he went to work as
00:23:25.082 --> 00:23:26.282
as an abolitionist trying
00:23:26.323 --> 00:23:28.125
to get slavery abolished in Delaware.
00:23:28.144 --> 00:23:30.247
And he tried three separate
00:23:30.267 --> 00:23:31.847
occasions or about three
00:23:31.867 --> 00:23:34.410
separate occasions to to
00:23:34.549 --> 00:23:35.611
end slavery in Delaware.
00:23:35.671 --> 00:23:37.133
But Delawareans would not
00:23:37.792 --> 00:23:40.055
they would not allow that to happen.
00:23:40.195 --> 00:23:41.636
It doesn't happen until the Civil War.
00:23:42.372 --> 00:23:43.393
Well, actually,
00:23:43.653 --> 00:23:44.634
it didn't happen until
00:23:44.714 --> 00:23:45.935
nineteen oh one because
00:23:45.996 --> 00:23:49.921
they refused to ratify the
00:23:49.941 --> 00:23:50.862
Thirteenth Amendment until
00:23:50.902 --> 00:23:51.521
nineteen oh one.
00:23:51.541 --> 00:23:52.923
Amazing.
00:23:52.963 --> 00:23:54.285
We're talking with Jane Calvert,
00:23:54.445 --> 00:23:56.488
author of Penman of the Founding,
00:23:56.508 --> 00:23:58.450
a biography of John Dickinson,
00:23:58.911 --> 00:23:59.932
as well as the Quaker
00:23:59.971 --> 00:24:01.192
constitutionalism and the
00:24:01.232 --> 00:24:02.755
political thought of John Dickinson.
00:24:03.367 --> 00:24:05.328
and also the chief editor of
00:24:05.348 --> 00:24:07.309
the John Dickinson Writings Project.
00:24:07.849 --> 00:24:10.131
And so you can see, I mean,
00:24:10.151 --> 00:24:11.031
you have the privilege of
00:24:11.071 --> 00:24:13.133
really being immersed in his writings.
00:24:13.272 --> 00:24:15.074
You know, the third volume,
00:24:16.269 --> 00:24:17.670
the Dickinson of the
00:24:17.690 --> 00:24:18.830
complete writings has come
00:24:18.911 --> 00:24:20.612
out and then volume four is
00:24:20.652 --> 00:24:21.512
anticipated next year.
00:24:21.532 --> 00:24:22.653
And volume four covers the
00:24:22.693 --> 00:24:24.996
years of the farmer's letters,
00:24:25.016 --> 00:24:27.698
I understand.
00:24:27.718 --> 00:24:27.778
Yes.
00:24:27.798 --> 00:24:29.278
Yeah, that's an exciting volume.
00:24:29.338 --> 00:24:32.520
It takes us up until seventeen sixty nine,
00:24:32.561 --> 00:24:34.262
and that should be out early,
00:24:34.542 --> 00:24:35.624
early twenty twenty five.
00:24:35.644 --> 00:24:37.525
Very good.
00:24:37.565 --> 00:24:38.826
So you can see in his
00:24:38.865 --> 00:24:40.647
writings the way he is
00:24:40.847 --> 00:24:42.429
wrestling with things as
00:24:42.528 --> 00:24:43.890
well as being this
00:24:45.355 --> 00:24:47.656
very interesting force and
00:24:47.696 --> 00:24:51.239
perspective on American thought.
00:24:52.279 --> 00:24:53.040
Yeah, absolutely.
00:24:53.060 --> 00:24:54.361
I mean, really,
00:24:55.501 --> 00:24:57.863
it's astounding how much
00:24:58.604 --> 00:24:59.984
how many of the documents
00:25:00.065 --> 00:25:01.105
central to the American
00:25:01.144 --> 00:25:04.827
founding Dickinson had drafted.
00:25:05.748 --> 00:25:06.888
There was really you know,
00:25:07.568 --> 00:25:08.970
I've been trying to think recently,
00:25:09.009 --> 00:25:10.851
like what I really can't
00:25:10.871 --> 00:25:11.932
think of any major
00:25:13.394 --> 00:25:14.414
aspect of the American
00:25:14.454 --> 00:25:15.455
founding that Dickinson
00:25:15.476 --> 00:25:16.876
didn't have something to do
00:25:16.916 --> 00:25:19.538
with and have something to say about.
00:25:19.999 --> 00:25:21.280
And he was just kind of
00:25:21.381 --> 00:25:22.561
everywhere all the time.
00:25:22.582 --> 00:25:23.602
Yeah.
00:25:23.622 --> 00:25:24.403
And very effective too.
00:25:24.423 --> 00:25:24.603
I mean,
00:25:24.623 --> 00:25:26.144
he's also at the Constitutional
00:25:26.163 --> 00:25:28.226
Convention where he's one
00:25:28.365 --> 00:25:30.627
of the folks pushing for
00:25:31.028 --> 00:25:32.009
the New Jersey plan,
00:25:32.028 --> 00:25:33.250
not because he sees it as
00:25:33.329 --> 00:25:35.031
perfect or wants to preserve the articles,
00:25:35.071 --> 00:25:35.291
but he
00:25:36.012 --> 00:25:37.193
sees what the nationalists
00:25:37.233 --> 00:25:38.555
are doing is going to turn
00:25:38.595 --> 00:25:39.895
people off completely.
00:25:40.556 --> 00:25:41.136
Well, actually,
00:25:41.477 --> 00:25:43.137
he was not in favor of
00:25:43.258 --> 00:25:44.519
either the Virginia Plan or
00:25:44.558 --> 00:25:45.440
the New Jersey Plan.
00:25:45.900 --> 00:25:47.480
And this is, I think,
00:25:47.602 --> 00:25:50.463
one of the sort of
00:25:50.503 --> 00:25:53.445
astounding failures of history
00:25:53.746 --> 00:25:55.247
you know, the writing of history,
00:25:55.987 --> 00:25:57.228
is that Dickinson was
00:25:57.387 --> 00:25:59.470
actually the person who
00:25:59.670 --> 00:26:01.471
first proposed what became
00:26:01.510 --> 00:26:02.872
the Connecticut Compromise.
00:26:03.271 --> 00:26:06.253
So he started saying like, look, you know,
00:26:06.433 --> 00:26:12.157
we need the representation to be both
00:26:12.878 --> 00:26:14.259
proportional in one house
00:26:14.520 --> 00:26:15.862
and equal in the other house.
00:26:16.123 --> 00:26:17.344
And he had a vision.
00:26:17.585 --> 00:26:18.685
He'd actually been talking
00:26:18.766 --> 00:26:20.008
since the farmer's letters
00:26:20.327 --> 00:26:23.352
about this idea of divided sovereignty.
00:26:24.032 --> 00:26:27.116
Now, most Englishmen, most Britons,
00:26:29.398 --> 00:26:30.259
They didn't believe that
00:26:30.279 --> 00:26:32.041
there could be like what
00:26:32.061 --> 00:26:33.682
they call a state within a state.
00:26:34.183 --> 00:26:36.125
And Dickinson actually was
00:26:36.826 --> 00:26:38.426
suggesting as early as
00:26:38.487 --> 00:26:41.049
seventeen sixty seven that
00:26:41.089 --> 00:26:44.071
there could be a state within a state.
00:26:44.092 --> 00:26:46.294
So an American state within
00:26:46.453 --> 00:26:47.575
a British state.
00:26:48.155 --> 00:26:49.896
And and then he he
00:26:50.817 --> 00:26:52.839
started refining that idea
00:26:53.280 --> 00:26:55.082
when he saw how poorly the
00:26:55.142 --> 00:26:56.564
Articles of Confederation
00:26:56.923 --> 00:26:57.984
were performing.
00:26:58.025 --> 00:26:58.704
So he had written the
00:26:58.746 --> 00:26:59.926
Articles of Confederation
00:27:00.186 --> 00:27:01.087
with a strong central
00:27:01.127 --> 00:27:02.429
government and the state
00:27:02.469 --> 00:27:04.250
subordinated to that government.
00:27:04.990 --> 00:27:06.593
But that's not how it was passed.
00:27:06.692 --> 00:27:08.734
And America under the
00:27:08.775 --> 00:27:09.836
Articles of Confederation
00:27:09.875 --> 00:27:10.936
was not functioning.
00:27:12.037 --> 00:27:14.837
So in the early seventeen eighties,
00:27:14.877 --> 00:27:17.817
he started describing what
00:27:17.877 --> 00:27:19.538
he saw as the relationship
00:27:19.578 --> 00:27:20.398
between the central
00:27:20.419 --> 00:27:22.798
government and the state governments.
00:27:23.038 --> 00:27:25.519
And he described it as a solar system.
00:27:25.799 --> 00:27:26.799
So with the central
00:27:26.819 --> 00:27:28.119
government like the sun and
00:27:28.140 --> 00:27:29.599
the states revolving around
00:27:29.660 --> 00:27:30.461
it like planets.
00:27:30.740 --> 00:27:31.740
And so he brought this
00:27:31.820 --> 00:27:32.780
metaphor to the
00:27:32.820 --> 00:27:34.181
Constitutional Convention.
00:27:34.740 --> 00:27:37.422
And when he said that there should be
00:27:38.001 --> 00:27:39.663
this representation in one
00:27:39.723 --> 00:27:41.365
house as proportional and
00:27:41.385 --> 00:27:42.487
the other one equal.
00:27:43.728 --> 00:27:46.131
But his colleagues didn't
00:27:46.151 --> 00:27:49.994
really hear him and he kept trying,
00:27:50.035 --> 00:27:51.536
but then eventually they
00:27:51.556 --> 00:27:55.660
went away and the committee
00:27:55.680 --> 00:27:56.461
that came up with the
00:27:56.500 --> 00:27:57.182
so-called Connecticut
00:27:57.281 --> 00:27:58.242
Compromise came back with
00:27:58.262 --> 00:28:00.444
the exact same proposal that he had made.
00:28:00.585 --> 00:28:00.746
Yeah.
00:28:01.413 --> 00:28:02.015
That's interesting.
00:28:02.675 --> 00:28:04.578
And so he plays a very active role there.
00:28:04.598 --> 00:28:05.559
And what happens during the
00:28:05.579 --> 00:28:06.961
ratification process?
00:28:07.142 --> 00:28:08.625
What kind of role does he play there?
00:28:09.337 --> 00:28:09.718
Yeah,
00:28:09.738 --> 00:28:11.759
so he had to leave the convention
00:28:11.799 --> 00:28:13.641
early because he was very
00:28:13.701 --> 00:28:14.641
sick for most of it.
00:28:15.201 --> 00:28:17.042
But he regained his health enough to,
00:28:18.884 --> 00:28:20.785
he was asked to write some
00:28:20.845 --> 00:28:24.346
letters to argue for ratification.
00:28:24.847 --> 00:28:26.608
And well, actually,
00:28:26.628 --> 00:28:27.849
I can't remember if he was
00:28:27.990 --> 00:28:29.170
asked or if he took it upon himself.
00:28:29.250 --> 00:28:29.790
But in any case,
00:28:30.070 --> 00:28:31.652
he wrote nine letters under
00:28:31.672 --> 00:28:32.732
the pen name Fabius.
00:28:33.192 --> 00:28:34.394
And these were published
00:28:35.094 --> 00:28:36.494
around the states.
00:28:37.496 --> 00:28:38.596
And they actually had a much
00:28:38.676 --> 00:28:40.877
wider reach than the Federalist Papers,
00:28:40.917 --> 00:28:42.298
which are so famous today,
00:28:42.338 --> 00:28:43.740
which were only really
00:28:43.780 --> 00:28:44.861
published in New York and
00:28:45.021 --> 00:28:46.643
only directed towards the elite.
00:28:47.123 --> 00:28:48.044
And Dickinson wrote these
00:28:48.084 --> 00:28:48.924
nine letters that were
00:28:48.964 --> 00:28:51.026
published in multiple states,
00:28:51.125 --> 00:28:51.987
and they were directed to
00:28:52.146 --> 00:28:53.607
ordinary individuals.
00:28:54.108 --> 00:28:58.352
And they were really seen very favorably,
00:28:58.531 --> 00:29:00.054
and even George Washington
00:29:00.094 --> 00:29:03.236
praised them as being very useful.
00:29:03.256 --> 00:29:03.936
Yeah.
00:29:04.679 --> 00:29:05.599
And Fabius, of course,
00:29:05.619 --> 00:29:07.299
is a pen name from ancient
00:29:07.359 --> 00:29:09.000
Rome that she's using.
00:29:09.902 --> 00:29:10.582
Yes, yes,
00:29:11.142 --> 00:29:12.403
it's a pen name from ancient Rome.
00:29:12.843 --> 00:29:16.085
And Washington was also
00:29:16.244 --> 00:29:18.205
called the American Fabius.
00:29:18.566 --> 00:29:20.366
But Dickinson, you know,
00:29:20.707 --> 00:29:24.689
so Fabius was known for being cautious.
00:29:25.249 --> 00:29:26.950
And I think that's generally
00:29:27.029 --> 00:29:28.971
what Americans, if they know Fabius,
00:29:29.010 --> 00:29:30.051
they kind of take it away.
00:29:30.471 --> 00:29:31.893
uh, the caution away,
00:29:32.292 --> 00:29:33.913
but actually Fabius was a
00:29:33.993 --> 00:29:36.174
really great name for Dickinson.
00:29:36.214 --> 00:29:36.715
And I, and,
00:29:36.816 --> 00:29:38.936
and the reason he chose it is because, um,
00:29:39.317 --> 00:29:41.018
Fabius was also a master
00:29:41.097 --> 00:29:43.839
strategist and was actually, uh,
00:29:44.140 --> 00:29:45.221
someone who won.
00:29:45.794 --> 00:29:47.153
through sort of guerrilla
00:29:47.213 --> 00:29:48.914
warfare tactics and
00:29:49.255 --> 00:29:50.575
unconventional tactics.
00:29:50.835 --> 00:29:52.914
And that really described Dickinson.
00:29:53.796 --> 00:29:56.056
Dickinson was very much, I mean,
00:29:56.175 --> 00:29:58.115
he was like a chess master,
00:29:58.436 --> 00:30:00.156
sort of manipulating the
00:30:00.176 --> 00:30:01.856
various factions in order
00:30:01.896 --> 00:30:03.096
to get them to go in the
00:30:03.136 --> 00:30:04.817
direction he wanted them to go.
00:30:05.077 --> 00:30:05.538
Right.
00:30:05.577 --> 00:30:06.857
We're talking with Jane Calvert,
00:30:07.038 --> 00:30:08.659
author of Penman of the Founding,
00:30:08.679 --> 00:30:10.598
a biography of John Dickinson.
00:30:11.508 --> 00:30:15.233
So what happens then to his legacy?
00:30:15.273 --> 00:30:15.473
I mean,
00:30:15.493 --> 00:30:17.036
we've talked about his relationship
00:30:17.076 --> 00:30:18.719
with Franklin, which
00:30:19.275 --> 00:30:20.996
wasn't that good and then
00:30:21.195 --> 00:30:23.196
franklin becomes of course
00:30:23.237 --> 00:30:24.698
the american model and of
00:30:24.758 --> 00:30:26.759
course then he's the one he
00:30:26.858 --> 00:30:28.078
proposes the convention why
00:30:28.098 --> 00:30:28.880
don't we have one house
00:30:28.920 --> 00:30:30.119
represent the population
00:30:30.141 --> 00:30:30.941
the other represent the
00:30:30.980 --> 00:30:31.901
states and no one listens
00:30:31.921 --> 00:30:33.461
to that but now connecticut
00:30:33.481 --> 00:30:34.403
of course calls itself the
00:30:34.442 --> 00:30:35.942
constitution state for that
00:30:36.443 --> 00:30:38.484
so why doesn't his
00:30:38.605 --> 00:30:41.205
reputation uh last the way
00:30:41.806 --> 00:30:43.146
others like you know we
00:30:43.166 --> 00:30:44.347
know reputations have a way
00:30:44.407 --> 00:30:46.449
of rising and falling and
00:30:46.628 --> 00:30:47.848
his I think you're just
00:30:47.868 --> 00:30:48.970
beginning to bring back
00:30:50.702 --> 00:30:52.984
Yeah, so just to be clear, I mean,
00:30:53.025 --> 00:30:53.766
Dickinson,
00:30:54.946 --> 00:30:58.711
very few people cared at all
00:30:58.871 --> 00:31:00.913
that he did not vote on or
00:31:00.933 --> 00:31:01.753
sign the Declaration of
00:31:01.794 --> 00:31:03.296
Independence in his day,
00:31:03.316 --> 00:31:04.837
because the Declaration was
00:31:04.938 --> 00:31:06.439
not seen as this kind of
00:31:06.499 --> 00:31:07.559
American scripture,
00:31:07.759 --> 00:31:09.962
as historians have called it,
00:31:10.623 --> 00:31:12.826
until the early nineteenth century.
00:31:13.486 --> 00:31:14.646
And Dickinson really
00:31:14.707 --> 00:31:17.230
retained his a good portion
00:31:17.269 --> 00:31:19.291
of his popularity, even celebrity.
00:31:20.212 --> 00:31:22.615
And he was known.
00:31:22.634 --> 00:31:23.935
And even after he retired,
00:31:24.356 --> 00:31:26.038
the public just clamored
00:31:26.077 --> 00:31:27.759
for him to return to office.
00:31:28.861 --> 00:31:29.560
And he had to sort of
00:31:29.902 --> 00:31:33.744
decline to be elected multiple times.
00:31:35.207 --> 00:31:36.048
When he died,
00:31:37.148 --> 00:31:40.231
the celebrations of his life
00:31:41.012 --> 00:31:44.076
were such that only George
00:31:44.135 --> 00:31:46.317
Washington before him,
00:31:47.318 --> 00:31:50.241
only those public displays
00:31:50.281 --> 00:31:53.065
of grief were more than Dickinson's.
00:31:54.625 --> 00:31:55.807
Why don't we know him today?
00:31:56.228 --> 00:31:57.990
That's the million-dollar question.
00:31:58.990 --> 00:32:00.231
There are a few reasons.
00:32:01.472 --> 00:32:03.355
First and probably easiest
00:32:03.375 --> 00:32:04.596
to understand is just that
00:32:04.635 --> 00:32:06.057
his papers weren't available.
00:32:07.417 --> 00:32:08.680
He did not take a whole lot
00:32:08.700 --> 00:32:10.000
of care with his own papers.
00:32:10.240 --> 00:32:11.382
He wasn't obsessed with his
00:32:11.422 --> 00:32:14.404
legacy the way other big
00:32:14.444 --> 00:32:15.365
name founders were.
00:32:15.905 --> 00:32:18.167
And so his papers actually
00:32:18.208 --> 00:32:19.167
did not show up in the
00:32:19.228 --> 00:32:20.489
archives until the early
00:32:21.289 --> 00:32:22.289
twentieth century.
00:32:22.730 --> 00:32:24.731
And so there was not very
00:32:26.353 --> 00:32:27.294
there weren't the materials
00:32:27.334 --> 00:32:29.795
to be able to write a biography.
00:32:29.835 --> 00:32:32.217
So that that's just one very obvious,
00:32:32.336 --> 00:32:33.357
easy reason to understand,
00:32:33.377 --> 00:32:34.438
because every other major
00:32:34.458 --> 00:32:38.760
founder has had his papers published in,
00:32:39.040 --> 00:32:39.721
you know,
00:32:40.241 --> 00:32:42.703
tens of volumes um so
00:32:42.903 --> 00:32:43.964
anytime someone wants to
00:32:43.984 --> 00:32:44.986
write a biography they just
00:32:45.026 --> 00:32:46.027
have to open those up and
00:32:46.106 --> 00:32:47.167
all the source materials
00:32:47.208 --> 00:32:48.308
right there okay so
00:32:48.328 --> 00:32:49.349
dickinson did not have that
00:32:50.171 --> 00:32:52.393
but then I think um if then
00:32:52.532 --> 00:32:55.115
then the second reason I
00:32:55.154 --> 00:32:55.935
think he's not known is
00:32:55.976 --> 00:32:57.376
because um people did not
00:32:57.457 --> 00:32:58.898
understand his quakerism
00:32:59.338 --> 00:33:01.540
and to be clear he was not a quaker
00:33:01.941 --> 00:33:04.701
but he embraced so much of
00:33:04.801 --> 00:33:06.982
the Quaker sort of political thought.
00:33:07.462 --> 00:33:08.403
And that's just not
00:33:08.443 --> 00:33:10.585
something that Americans
00:33:10.605 --> 00:33:12.746
have not generally put a
00:33:12.826 --> 00:33:16.146
lot of credence with the
00:33:16.166 --> 00:33:17.928
religion of the founders.
00:33:18.488 --> 00:33:20.628
And Quakerism is a dissenting religion,
00:33:21.288 --> 00:33:22.930
so it was at odds with the
00:33:23.609 --> 00:33:25.810
mainstream of American religion,
00:33:25.851 --> 00:33:27.751
which was usually Calvinism.
00:33:28.991 --> 00:33:29.972
So that was one thing,
00:33:30.012 --> 00:33:30.894
just sort of confusion
00:33:30.933 --> 00:33:32.954
about what Dickinson stood
00:33:32.994 --> 00:33:35.557
for and why he didn't sign
00:33:35.596 --> 00:33:36.778
the Declaration of Independence.
00:33:37.358 --> 00:33:39.059
But then I think if there's
00:33:39.299 --> 00:33:42.321
one single biggest reason,
00:33:43.242 --> 00:33:45.345
I would say it was probably John Adams.
00:33:46.025 --> 00:33:48.547
And so John Adams was he
00:33:48.606 --> 00:33:49.788
started out a fan of
00:33:49.847 --> 00:33:51.128
Dickinson's like pretty
00:33:51.169 --> 00:33:52.690
much everybody else when he
00:33:53.390 --> 00:33:54.211
when he joined the
00:33:54.250 --> 00:33:55.991
resistance movement in in
00:33:56.031 --> 00:33:57.012
seventeen seventy four.
00:33:57.053 --> 00:33:58.953
Dickinson had been doing it for ten years,
00:33:59.654 --> 00:34:00.875
more than ten years at that point.
00:34:01.476 --> 00:34:02.576
Yeah, about ten years.
00:34:04.135 --> 00:34:05.998
And Adams came to Philadelphia, you know,
00:34:06.018 --> 00:34:07.198
kind of starstruck and
00:34:07.219 --> 00:34:08.338
wanting to meet the famous
00:34:08.579 --> 00:34:10.039
Pennsylvania farmer and
00:34:10.059 --> 00:34:11.742
just kind of practically swooned,
00:34:11.762 --> 00:34:13.623
you know, writing about Dickinson.
00:34:14.143 --> 00:34:16.405
But then when Dickinson
00:34:16.445 --> 00:34:17.885
joined the first Congress
00:34:18.385 --> 00:34:20.266
and his writing started to
00:34:20.306 --> 00:34:21.648
supplant Adams' writings
00:34:21.688 --> 00:34:22.528
for the first Congress,
00:34:22.909 --> 00:34:25.630
Adams became annoyed and
00:34:25.690 --> 00:34:27.152
then very jealous.
00:34:27.331 --> 00:34:29.273
And if you know anything about Adams,
00:34:29.793 --> 00:34:32.014
he tended to be sort of a, you know,
00:34:32.034 --> 00:34:33.155
a very sort of jealous,
00:34:34.295 --> 00:34:36.036
kind of vindictive character.
00:34:37.577 --> 00:34:38.677
And so at that point,
00:34:38.817 --> 00:34:41.617
he kind of made it his goal
00:34:41.677 --> 00:34:44.018
in life to take down Dickinson.
00:34:44.557 --> 00:34:50.438
And where he had most success was in,
00:34:50.480 --> 00:34:54.300
so Dickinson,
00:34:55.400 --> 00:34:57.021
he controlled both the First
00:34:57.081 --> 00:34:58.161
and the Second Continental
00:34:58.221 --> 00:35:01.262
Congress really without challenge.
00:35:02.722 --> 00:35:05.503
And so he he said in
00:35:05.543 --> 00:35:06.983
seventeen seventy five that
00:35:07.184 --> 00:35:08.204
we should be you know,
00:35:08.264 --> 00:35:09.423
America should be preparing
00:35:09.764 --> 00:35:11.905
for peaceful negotiations
00:35:12.264 --> 00:35:13.985
and for war simultaneously.
00:35:14.385 --> 00:35:15.507
Adams was one hundred
00:35:15.527 --> 00:35:19.027
percent convinced of that.
00:35:19.248 --> 00:35:20.668
And and and, you know,
00:35:20.748 --> 00:35:23.148
he he he voted for both the
00:35:23.228 --> 00:35:24.909
olive branch petition and
00:35:25.130 --> 00:35:26.530
the declaration on taking up arms,
00:35:26.590 --> 00:35:27.731
both of which Dickinson wrote.
00:35:29.148 --> 00:35:30.869
And he was fine with all those things.
00:35:31.911 --> 00:35:33.492
But then after all that was done,
00:35:34.034 --> 00:35:35.034
Adams started to get
00:35:35.094 --> 00:35:36.456
irritated with his fellow
00:35:36.496 --> 00:35:38.239
Massachusetts delegates and
00:35:38.298 --> 00:35:39.880
he started lashing out at
00:35:40.240 --> 00:35:41.362
everybody around him.
00:35:41.862 --> 00:35:44.445
And he wrote this now famous
00:35:44.786 --> 00:35:47.228
or infamous letter calling Dickinson
00:35:47.568 --> 00:35:49.710
a great fortune and piddling genius.
00:35:49.952 --> 00:35:52.675
And this letter was
00:35:53.094 --> 00:35:55.356
intercepted by the British and published.
00:35:55.898 --> 00:35:59.282
And so everybody knew.
00:35:59.561 --> 00:36:02.144
And they actually ostracized Adams,
00:36:02.565 --> 00:36:04.186
because Dickinson was
00:36:04.226 --> 00:36:06.148
someone that everybody
00:36:06.268 --> 00:36:07.110
loved and respected.
00:36:08.210 --> 00:36:11.793
But then Adams actually, he recanted.
00:36:11.853 --> 00:36:12.753
He took it back.
00:36:13.934 --> 00:36:15.795
He basically said, oh, well,
00:36:15.896 --> 00:36:17.277
I was just in a bad mood,
00:36:17.436 --> 00:36:20.559
and I know he's actually very smart,
00:36:20.599 --> 00:36:24.181
and he's very patriotic, and so on.
00:36:26.751 --> 00:36:28.733
Flash forward to, I mean,
00:36:30.695 --> 00:36:32.016
Adams was still very,
00:36:32.597 --> 00:36:33.798
very jealous of Dickinson
00:36:34.059 --> 00:36:35.681
and actually had credited
00:36:37.081 --> 00:36:39.625
Dickinson and his wife for
00:36:41.206 --> 00:36:44.230
Adams losing reelection to president.
00:36:45.190 --> 00:36:46.690
And so that's sort of amazing.
00:36:47.030 --> 00:36:48.271
But then in eighteen oh five,
00:36:48.391 --> 00:36:50.391
he Adams recounted this
00:36:50.431 --> 00:36:53.353
whole episode that where he
00:36:53.393 --> 00:36:55.353
wrote that piddling genius letter.
00:36:55.934 --> 00:36:59.375
And he kind of fabricated a story that,
00:36:59.414 --> 00:36:59.856
you know,
00:37:00.036 --> 00:37:02.436
that he he had that he and
00:37:02.456 --> 00:37:05.077
Dickinson had had this this big, you know,
00:37:05.157 --> 00:37:05.938
confrontation.
00:37:06.918 --> 00:37:09.199
And so he was frustrated and
00:37:09.260 --> 00:37:12.202
called Dickinson this name.
00:37:12.503 --> 00:37:14.445
But there's not really any
00:37:14.525 --> 00:37:16.126
evidence from the time that
00:37:16.226 --> 00:37:17.969
this confrontation happened.
00:37:17.989 --> 00:37:19.210
I mean, maybe it did,
00:37:19.250 --> 00:37:20.570
but Adams didn't mention it.
00:37:20.670 --> 00:37:21.711
No one mentioned it.
00:37:22.313 --> 00:37:24.315
And so it's very doubtful
00:37:24.335 --> 00:37:25.536
whether it actually happened.
00:37:26.076 --> 00:37:27.297
And then...
00:37:28.097 --> 00:37:29.518
When the historians in the
00:37:29.619 --> 00:37:30.639
early nineteenth century,
00:37:30.679 --> 00:37:31.880
particularly one historian
00:37:31.920 --> 00:37:32.780
named George Bancroft,
00:37:33.501 --> 00:37:34.782
when he wrote his
00:37:35.101 --> 00:37:38.123
multi-volume history of the
00:37:38.164 --> 00:37:39.025
American Revolution,
00:37:39.385 --> 00:37:42.467
he drew on Adams' diary.
00:37:43.106 --> 00:37:45.427
And he also drew on Jefferson,
00:37:45.728 --> 00:37:46.809
and Jefferson had actually
00:37:46.849 --> 00:37:48.150
taken credit for the
00:37:48.190 --> 00:37:49.550
Declaration on Taking Up Arms,
00:37:49.570 --> 00:37:50.311
which Dickinson,
00:37:51.072 --> 00:37:52.132
he drafted the belligerent
00:37:52.172 --> 00:37:52.793
language in that.
00:37:53.574 --> 00:37:56.365
So basically, mainly Adams,
00:37:56.405 --> 00:37:57.913
but also Jefferson,
00:37:59.563 --> 00:38:01.804
They fabricated stories and
00:38:01.844 --> 00:38:03.364
took credit away from Dickinson.
00:38:03.784 --> 00:38:05.385
And historians not having
00:38:05.485 --> 00:38:07.065
access to Dickinson's own
00:38:07.567 --> 00:38:09.766
papers just took everything
00:38:10.146 --> 00:38:11.487
Jefferson and Adams said at
00:38:11.527 --> 00:38:12.967
face value and painted
00:38:13.007 --> 00:38:14.829
Dickinson as this sort of
00:38:15.108 --> 00:38:17.429
disloyal and effeminate
00:38:17.869 --> 00:38:20.750
foil to the manly Atlas of Independence,
00:38:20.771 --> 00:38:21.471
John Adams.
00:38:22.030 --> 00:38:23.871
And then David McCullough picked that up.
00:38:24.431 --> 00:38:26.072
And then the HBO miniseries
00:38:26.132 --> 00:38:26.891
picked that up.
00:38:27.072 --> 00:38:28.813
And so it just sort of snowballed.
00:38:29.152 --> 00:38:30.253
Well, Jane,
00:38:30.273 --> 00:38:31.333
can we talk a little bit about
00:38:31.934 --> 00:38:33.114
how we're correcting that
00:38:33.155 --> 00:38:34.556
by publishing the complete
00:38:34.576 --> 00:38:35.617
writings and selected
00:38:35.657 --> 00:38:37.077
correspondence of John Dickinson,
00:38:37.097 --> 00:38:38.298
the John Dickinson Project,
00:38:38.338 --> 00:38:40.219
and how that came into being and what
00:38:41.889 --> 00:38:43.050
What's happened?
00:38:43.090 --> 00:38:43.309
Well,
00:38:43.670 --> 00:38:46.731
so when I finished my first book on
00:38:46.791 --> 00:38:47.371
Dickinson,
00:38:47.572 --> 00:38:49.452
I realized that somebody really
00:38:49.492 --> 00:38:51.454
needed to publish his
00:38:51.474 --> 00:38:52.414
writings because there were
00:38:52.574 --> 00:38:53.434
so many of them.
00:38:53.974 --> 00:38:56.876
And most people had no idea
00:38:57.396 --> 00:38:58.416
that Dickinson had written
00:38:58.657 --> 00:39:00.798
these seminal documents and
00:39:00.878 --> 00:39:01.818
had written so much.
00:39:02.199 --> 00:39:04.139
And so I didn't much want to
00:39:04.179 --> 00:39:05.521
become a documentary editor
00:39:05.740 --> 00:39:07.422
because it's really the hardest thing
00:39:07.621 --> 00:39:09.722
that anyone can do in the
00:39:09.742 --> 00:39:10.663
historical profession.
00:39:11.262 --> 00:39:15.284
And so, but I started the project in, in,
00:39:16.264 --> 00:39:18.804
and, you know, we've been going,
00:39:20.045 --> 00:39:21.606
gaining momentum and,
00:39:22.286 --> 00:39:24.286
and we have an amazing team
00:39:24.726 --> 00:39:26.108
and we're about to, you know,
00:39:26.128 --> 00:39:28.668
publish volume four of about thirteen.
00:39:30.108 --> 00:39:31.188
The challenge, however,
00:39:31.369 --> 00:39:37.110
is that the sort of the, the,
00:39:38.652 --> 00:39:41.112
elite white male figures are
00:39:41.152 --> 00:39:43.235
kind of out of vogue in the academy.
00:39:43.755 --> 00:39:47.496
And in fact, the Dickinson,
00:39:47.737 --> 00:39:48.637
the John Dickinson Writings
00:39:48.657 --> 00:39:51.318
Project was just denied renewed funding,
00:39:51.378 --> 00:39:52.360
even though, you know,
00:39:52.380 --> 00:39:53.579
we've made just remarkable
00:39:53.639 --> 00:39:54.880
progress and fulfilled all
00:39:54.900 --> 00:39:56.001
of our performance objectives.
00:39:56.041 --> 00:39:58.623
But one of the federal agencies that funds
00:39:59.643 --> 00:40:01.365
these projects has sort of
00:40:01.445 --> 00:40:04.889
moved away from funding the
00:40:04.929 --> 00:40:07.211
founders papers projects.
00:40:07.552 --> 00:40:08.373
And so, you know,
00:40:08.454 --> 00:40:09.034
now we're kind of
00:40:09.074 --> 00:40:10.715
scrambling to try to raise
00:40:10.755 --> 00:40:13.820
money to retain our, you know,
00:40:13.980 --> 00:40:15.240
our wonderful staff who are
00:40:15.260 --> 00:40:17.764
doing such great work.
00:40:17.804 --> 00:40:19.166
So where is the project based?
00:40:20.391 --> 00:40:22.132
Well, it's sort of, you know,
00:40:22.172 --> 00:40:24.813
technically based with me.
00:40:25.693 --> 00:40:28.094
It's mine and wherever I go,
00:40:28.414 --> 00:40:29.474
it comes with me.
00:40:30.916 --> 00:40:32.936
It is actually at the moment
00:40:33.777 --> 00:40:35.518
based at the University of Delaware,
00:40:35.838 --> 00:40:38.440
but we're going to be transitioning to,
00:40:38.500 --> 00:40:39.980
you know,
00:40:40.059 --> 00:40:42.280
to a new host institution before
00:40:42.320 --> 00:40:42.862
too long.
00:40:42.961 --> 00:40:45.322
There have been, unfortunately,
00:40:45.722 --> 00:40:46.943
staffing and budget cuts at
00:40:47.003 --> 00:40:47.943
University of Delaware.
00:40:49.184 --> 00:40:52.244
But we will hopefully
00:40:52.284 --> 00:40:56.965
continue and we just need
00:40:56.985 --> 00:40:58.405
to make sure we can secure
00:40:58.726 --> 00:41:00.246
funding because documentary
00:41:00.306 --> 00:41:02.246
editing is extraordinarily
00:41:02.286 --> 00:41:03.226
difficult and labor
00:41:03.266 --> 00:41:07.347
intensive and Dickinson's writings are
00:41:08.327 --> 00:41:09.648
really the most challenging
00:41:09.688 --> 00:41:10.869
of any of the founders
00:41:11.530 --> 00:41:13.771
because of his education
00:41:14.050 --> 00:41:16.831
and his knowledge in the
00:41:16.851 --> 00:41:20.114
law and also his messy, messy drafts,
00:41:20.134 --> 00:41:21.434
which are very difficult to read.
00:41:23.434 --> 00:41:24.795
That's an amazing project.
00:41:24.956 --> 00:41:26.936
Let's hope we can keep it going.
00:41:26.956 --> 00:41:27.978
It sounds like something
00:41:28.057 --> 00:41:30.978
well worth pursuing that
00:41:31.018 --> 00:41:32.480
the nine volumes that are
00:41:32.780 --> 00:41:33.659
out there waiting,
00:41:33.719 --> 00:41:35.641
tell a big story about the revolution,
00:41:35.661 --> 00:41:36.742
the constitution,
00:41:37.882 --> 00:41:38.242
Adams,
00:41:38.322 --> 00:41:40.623
the Washington Adams Jefferson Presidency,
00:41:41.704 --> 00:41:42.644
as well as what's happening
00:41:42.664 --> 00:41:43.864
in Delaware and Pennsylvania.
00:41:44.646 --> 00:41:45.425
Yes, absolutely.
00:41:46.206 --> 00:41:48.987
So we've been talking with Jane Calvert,
00:41:49.068 --> 00:41:50.548
who is the author of Penman
00:41:50.568 --> 00:41:51.128
of the Founding,
00:41:51.148 --> 00:41:53.670
a Biography of John Dickinson, historian,
00:41:53.730 --> 00:41:55.010
documentary editor,
00:41:55.150 --> 00:41:56.452
the director and chief
00:41:56.512 --> 00:41:57.231
editor of the John
00:41:57.271 --> 00:41:58.693
Dickinson Writings Project.
00:41:59.492 --> 00:42:01.054
So thank you so much for joining us, Jane.
00:42:01.074 --> 00:42:02.335
It's been really fun to talk
00:42:02.375 --> 00:42:03.434
to you about John Dickinson.
00:42:04.115 --> 00:42:04.856
Yeah, thank you so much.
00:42:04.876 --> 00:42:06.257
It's been a lot of fun.
00:42:06.277 --> 00:42:06.697
Great book.
00:42:07.396 --> 00:42:09.038
And I want to thank Jonathan Lane,
00:42:09.057 --> 00:42:09.757
our producer,
00:42:09.918 --> 00:42:11.639
and our listeners in and
00:42:11.679 --> 00:42:12.621
around the world.
00:42:12.681 --> 00:42:13.862
And every week I thank folks
00:42:13.882 --> 00:42:14.782
in different parts of the
00:42:14.822 --> 00:42:16.643
world who are regularly tuning in.
00:42:16.684 --> 00:42:17.385
And if you're in one of
00:42:17.405 --> 00:42:18.525
these places and want some
00:42:18.545 --> 00:42:20.307
of our Revolution Two-Fifty swag,
00:42:20.327 --> 00:42:21.668
send Jonathan Lane an email,
00:42:21.708 --> 00:42:23.731
jlaneatrevolutiontwofifty.org.
00:42:24.411 --> 00:42:25.152
Or if you're not in one of
00:42:25.172 --> 00:42:26.193
these places and just want
00:42:26.213 --> 00:42:26.873
to get in touch with
00:42:26.913 --> 00:42:27.893
Jonathan and suggest
00:42:27.914 --> 00:42:28.614
something you'd like to
00:42:28.635 --> 00:42:30.315
hear about on the podcast, let him know,
00:42:31.476 --> 00:42:33.739
jlaneatrevolutiontwofifty.org.
00:42:33.759 --> 00:42:34.280
So this week,
00:42:34.755 --> 00:42:35.454
I want to thank our
00:42:35.494 --> 00:42:37.396
listeners in Prague and in
00:42:38.016 --> 00:42:40.096
Muang Samut Prakan in Thailand,
00:42:40.235 --> 00:42:42.717
in Dhaka in Bangladesh, Shaman Jordan,
00:42:42.916 --> 00:42:45.597
Edinburgh, Scotland, Dublin, Ireland,
00:42:46.197 --> 00:42:48.518
Vienna, Maine, Coolidge, Arizona,
00:42:48.659 --> 00:42:49.778
East Hampton here in the
00:42:49.818 --> 00:42:51.759
Commonwealth of Massachusetts, Uncasville,
00:42:51.778 --> 00:42:52.280
Connecticut,
00:42:52.300 --> 00:42:53.940
and all places between and beyond.
00:42:53.980 --> 00:42:54.920
Thanks for joining us.
00:42:54.960 --> 00:42:56.780
And now we will be piped out
00:42:56.880 --> 00:42:57.800
on the road to Boston.