Revolution 250 Podcast

George Washington and the American Crisis with William M. Fowler

August 01, 2023 William M. Fowler Season 4 Episode 31
Revolution 250 Podcast
George Washington and the American Crisis with William M. Fowler
Show Notes Transcript

When the British surrendered at Yorktown, the war ended and American independence was secure.  Or was it?   The British still occupied Savannah, Charleston, and New York City, and the Congress was not able to pay the American army.  During the two years between Cornwallis's surrender and the final British evacuation, George Washington faced one of the gravest crises in American history--an attempt by some of his officers to usurp the authority of Congress and establish themselves in power.  Would Washington go along?  We talk with William M. Fowler, author of American Crisis:  George Washington and the Dangerous Two Years After Yorktown 1781-1783.  You thought winning the war was difficult--wait till you hear about winning the peace!  

WEBVTT
 
 00:00.683 --> 00:03.545
 Welcome, everyone, to the Revolution 250 podcast.
 
 00:03.605 --> 00:04.385
 I'm Bob Allison.
 
 00:04.425 --> 00:12.691
 I chair the Rev 250 advisory group, and we are a consortium of 70 groups in Massachusetts looking at ways to commemorate the beginnings of the American Revolution.
 
 00:13.091 --> 00:24.358
 And our guest today is Bill Fowler, William M. Fowler, Jr., a distinguished professor of history, emeritus, Northeastern University, the author of many books on the revolutionary era and on maritime history.
 
 00:24.799 --> 00:28.781
 But today we're going to talk about George Washington in the years after the revolution.
 
 00:28.801 --> 00:29.902
 So, Bill, thanks for joining us.
 
 00:30.472 --> 00:31.393
 Well, thank you, Bob.
 
 00:31.433 --> 00:33.514
 It's a pleasure to be with you and all of your listeners.
 
 00:34.414 --> 00:38.017
 So, Bill, we know about Washington as commander-in-chief.
 
 00:38.057 --> 00:43.920
 So then what happens when the war ends to Washington and his army, and why is this important?
 
 00:44.661 --> 00:48.904
 Well, you know, Bob, I think one of the most essential traits of a historian is curiosity.
 
 00:49.724 --> 00:55.027
 And for many years, I taught courses in the American Revolution and wrote some books about it as well.
 
 00:55.588 --> 00:55.708
 But
 
 00:56.243 --> 01:02.517
 For the popular image, the American Revolution sort of ends in 1781 with the surrender at Yorktown.
 
 01:02.937 --> 01:05.062
 But, of course, the peace doesn't come until late 1783.
 
 01:06.988 --> 01:08.469
 And so I was rather curious about this.
 
 01:08.529 --> 01:10.189
 What was going on in those two years?
 
 01:10.469 --> 01:13.551
 In particular, what was George Washington doing?
 
 01:14.651 --> 01:22.314
 Through research and through a lot of reading and visiting places, I love to visit historic sites, I began to put together a picture of those two years.
 
 01:22.854 --> 01:25.095
 And those two years, a lot was happening.
 
 01:25.495 --> 01:27.016
 Washington was very active.
 
 01:27.456 --> 01:30.237
 And in fact, the revolution was hardly over.
 
 01:31.117 --> 01:34.939
 Washington's victory at Yorktown ended one phase of the revolution.
 
 01:35.619 --> 01:39.660
 After that victory, the British were still in occupation of New York City.
 
 01:40.201 --> 01:41.861
 They still occupied Charleston.
 
 01:42.181 --> 01:45.862
 They were still very, very powerful Navy, powerful army.
 
 01:46.322 --> 01:47.523
 So what did happen?
 
 01:48.683 --> 01:55.125
 After Yorktown, Washington returned to the vicinity of New York City, which the British still occupied.
 
 01:55.965 --> 01:59.107
 And he took up his position at a place called Newburgh, New York.
 
 02:01.048 --> 02:03.730
 By the way, I encourage your listeners to visit Newburgh.
 
 02:03.790 --> 02:05.130
 It's a state historic site.
 
 02:06.391 --> 02:12.775
 Washington's army was there encamped at Newburgh watching over the British down in New York City.
 
 02:13.570 --> 02:16.995
 At the same time, after Yorktown, the French left.
 
 02:17.656 --> 02:21.581
 They had business elsewhere in the world, had to defend their possessions.
 
 02:22.102 --> 02:29.132
 So here is Washington with his army doing essentially nothing, watching the British down in New York City.
 
 02:29.815 --> 02:34.056
 In the meantime, the peace negotiations are going on in Paris.
 
 02:34.556 --> 02:36.476
 But they're taking a long time.
 
 02:36.756 --> 02:38.517
 Not much is happening.
 
 02:39.117 --> 02:44.238
 And the American army in Newburgh is becoming very uncomfortable.
 
 02:44.358 --> 02:45.058
 What is happening?
 
 02:45.458 --> 02:46.498
 Peace is in the air.
 
 02:47.639 --> 02:53.840
 In 1780, the Congress had agreed that the officers would be paid half pay for life.
 
 02:53.860 --> 02:55.420
 That's how they kept them in the army.
 
 02:55.920 --> 02:58.401
 But after 1780, the fact of the matter was the
 
 02:59.608 --> 03:00.909
 Congress had no money.
 
 03:01.389 --> 03:03.691
 And so the officers are becoming quite agitated.
 
 03:04.151 --> 03:05.693
 They don't know quite what's going on.
 
 03:05.753 --> 03:07.654
 The British are still down there in New York.
 
 03:07.954 --> 03:09.495
 They don't think they're going to get paid.
 
 03:09.556 --> 03:12.037
 They don't trust the Congress, et cetera, et cetera.
 
 03:13.138 --> 03:17.862
 In the midst of this, there arrives at the Newburgh encampment, General Horatio Gates.
 
 03:18.863 --> 03:24.927
 General Horatio Gates and George Washington had a long, unhappy relationship.
 
 03:25.367 --> 03:27.249
 They detested one another.
 
 03:27.925 --> 03:31.946
 But Gates had influence in Congress, so Congress set him up to Newburgh.
 
 03:32.427 --> 03:39.029
 And he took up his headquarters at a place called Ellison House, not far from the Newburgh encampment where Washington and the Army was.
 
 03:40.209 --> 03:42.610
 Well, in the meantime, of course, agitation.
 
 03:42.810 --> 03:43.751
 Agitation.
 
 03:43.911 --> 03:44.811
 Are we going to be paid?
 
 03:44.891 --> 03:45.731
 Who's going to pay us?
 
 03:45.851 --> 03:46.572
 Is the war over?
 
 03:46.612 --> 03:47.272
 What's going on?
 
 03:47.312 --> 03:47.792
 What's going on?
 
 03:49.195 --> 03:52.158
 And there are a few young officers serving under Gates.
 
 03:52.618 --> 03:57.383
 These are ambitious, let me be frank, somewhat unscrupulous men.
 
 03:58.604 --> 04:02.507
 They are friends of Gates and not friends of Washington.
 
 04:03.188 --> 04:04.009
 They're very impatient.
 
 04:04.029 --> 04:05.931
 They think Washington is doing nothing, doing nothing.
 
 04:06.491 --> 04:11.576
 And so they send out an announcement to the officers at the Newburgh encampment.
 
 04:12.213 --> 04:16.014
 And they announced that there's going to be a very special meeting.
 
 04:16.974 --> 04:19.535
 All of the offices on March the 11th.
 
 04:19.975 --> 04:25.316
 And they're going to meet in a building called, interestingly enough, the Temple of Virtue.
 
 04:26.436 --> 04:32.118
 During the encampment, just to keep the men busy, Washington had them building huts and laying out roads.
 
 04:32.778 --> 04:35.679
 And the Temple of Virtue was kind of an assembly hall.
 
 04:37.965 --> 04:41.947
 But Washington had not had anything to do with this March 11th meeting.
 
 04:42.707 --> 04:47.829
 As soon as he got notice, as soon as he got notice, can I just?
 
 04:48.349 --> 04:48.549
 Yeah.
 
 04:50.150 --> 04:56.492
 As soon as he got notice that this meeting was going to take place, he realized there was a conspiracy afoot.
 
 04:57.092 --> 04:58.733
 The conspiracy was against him.
 
 05:03.089 --> 05:05.070
 And the conspiracy was against him.
 
 05:06.350 --> 05:09.211
 So he immediately canceled the meeting.
 
 05:09.671 --> 05:16.354
 But he understood that he could not ignore the pleas, the concerns of his officers.
 
 05:17.294 --> 05:22.256
 So while he canceled the meeting on March 11th, he said, we will meet on March 15th.
 
 05:23.256 --> 05:26.817
 Commander in Chief, he was organizing this meeting.
 
 05:27.197 --> 05:32.139
 So for about four days, March 11th or so to March 10th,
 
 05:32.469 --> 05:34.690
 There's a lot of activity at Newburgh.
 
 05:35.450 --> 05:37.631
 Washington is busy with his officers.
 
 05:38.192 --> 05:41.653
 And what he is doing is he's trying to manage this meeting.
 
 05:42.214 --> 05:44.795
 He knows that tensions are rising high.
 
 05:45.455 --> 05:52.078
 If he doesn't placate the officers, if he doesn't address them and answer their queries, he's in danger.
 
 05:52.098 --> 05:52.799
 Mutiny.
 
 05:53.079 --> 05:54.439
 Mutiny is in the air.
 
 05:55.020 --> 05:56.620
 And so he consults with his officers.
 
 05:57.101 --> 06:02.303
 And during this time, he writes a speech that he intends to deliver.
 
 06:03.268 --> 06:09.529
 On March 15th at noon, at the appointed hour, the officers assemble at the Temple of Virtue.
 
 06:10.749 --> 06:15.610
 When they assembled, they did not know that Washington was going to attend the meeting.
 
 06:16.111 --> 06:17.491
 He hadn't been clear on that.
 
 06:18.131 --> 06:22.232
 And so the meeting is convened by General Gates.
 
 06:23.312 --> 06:24.592
 Gates convenes the meeting.
 
 06:25.452 --> 06:28.853
 As he is convening the meeting, Washington, the consummate actor,
 
 06:30.174 --> 06:34.818
 rides up to the Temple of Virtue, and outside the guard hears the sound of hoofs.
 
 06:35.459 --> 06:37.881
 And there through the door comes the commander-in-chief.
 
 06:38.341 --> 06:39.902
 Now imagine this for a moment.
 
 06:40.283 --> 06:42.685
 Washington is a big man, about six foot.
 
 06:43.165 --> 06:49.371
 He enters this room dressed always as he was, elegantly in the blue uniform of a continental officer.
 
 06:50.151 --> 06:55.276
 The men in the room, about 300 of them, are startled to see him, the commander-in-chief there.
 
 06:56.016 --> 06:57.658
 So they immediately come to attention.
 
 06:58.368 --> 06:59.969
 He walks to the front of the room.
 
 07:00.509 --> 07:03.210
 General Gates moves aside.
 
 07:03.230 --> 07:06.351
 Washington takes charge of the meeting.
 
 07:07.131 --> 07:15.795
 It is at this moment that he delivers to them perhaps one of the most important speeches of his entire life.
 
 07:16.926 --> 07:17.986
 Room is tense.
 
 07:18.767 --> 07:22.208
 Everyone is waiting to hear what will the general say.
 
 07:23.088 --> 07:27.870
 He delivers a speech, not very long, about five, six minutes maybe.
 
 07:28.271 --> 07:40.015
 And let me just read you what he said to them at the end of that speech, because this is a very, very emotional moment, emotional for Washington, as well as for his officers.
 
 07:41.056 --> 07:41.736
 He says to them,
 
 07:42.932 --> 08:06.484
 Let me conjure you in the name of our common country as you value your own sacred honor, as you respect the rights of humanity, and as you regard the military and national character of America to express your utmost horror and detestation of the man who wishes under any species pretenses to overturn the liberties of our country.
 
 08:07.176 --> 08:14.607
 and who wickedly attempts to open the floodgates of civil discord and deluge our rising empire in blood.
 
 08:15.188 --> 08:18.513
 Here, of course, he is talking about General Gates.
 
 08:19.414 --> 08:20.997
 He goes on to say to these men,
 
 08:21.977 --> 08:28.841
 By thus determining and thus acting, you will pursue the plain and direct road to the attainment of your wishes.
 
 08:29.422 --> 08:36.686
 You will defeat the insidious designs of our enemies who are compelled to resort from open force to secret artifice.
 
 08:37.306 --> 08:46.652
 You will give one more distinguished proof of unexampled patriotism and patient virtue, rising superior to the pressure of the most complicated sufferings.
 
 08:47.192 --> 08:50.034
 And you will, by the dignity of your conduct,
 
 08:50.640 --> 09:07.009
 for an occasion for posterity to say when speaking of this glorious example you have exhibited to mankind, quote, had this day been wanting, the world has never seen the last stage of perfection to which human nature is capable of attaining.
 
 09:08.089 --> 09:12.892
 There was not a dry eye in the box.
 
 09:13.592 --> 09:15.413
 The officers were in tears.
 
 09:16.333 --> 09:18.975
 Washington then folded up his speech
 
 09:20.376 --> 09:24.339
 and left, leaving the officers in silence.
 
 09:25.320 --> 09:31.725
 A few moments passed, and then the officers agreed and voted unanimously to support the commander in chief.
 
 09:32.446 --> 09:36.829
 In that one moment, Washington pushed aside a mutiny.
 
 09:37.329 --> 09:41.713
 He had reassigned himself, connected himself with the men who loved him so much.
 
 09:41.993 --> 09:44.095
 He had saved the revolution and saved
 
 09:44.795 --> 09:49.198
 although they might not have even deserved it, have saved the authority of Congress.
 
 09:50.359 --> 09:53.841
 And so the officers settled down and awaited.
 
 09:54.821 --> 09:57.863
 Not long after that speech, news came from Paris.
 
 09:58.624 --> 10:01.846
 And the news from Paris was that peace had been established.
 
 10:02.543 --> 10:06.084
 Not the final peace, mind you, but peace nonetheless.
 
 10:06.825 --> 10:10.486
 And so now the officers wanted nothing more than to go home.
 
 10:10.506 --> 10:20.890
 So whatever their grievances were, whatever they expected from Congress, what really was most high in their minds was home, home, home.
 
 10:21.490 --> 10:26.032
 And so most of the officers disbanded from Newburgh and returned home.
 
 10:27.232 --> 10:31.654
 And then there was one more event that Washington needed to attend to.
 
 10:32.955 --> 10:37.699
 With peace, the British were required to abandon to evacuate New York City.
 
 10:38.219 --> 10:45.225
 The British commander in New York City was Sir Guy Compton, a very distinguished British military officer.
 
 10:46.086 --> 10:50.209
 Sir Guy had arrived in New York in the spring of 1782.
 
 10:50.690 --> 10:57.495
 The British ministry had sent him there, so he thought, to finish the revolution.
 
 10:58.756 --> 11:00.758
 They had been somewhat disingenuous.
 
 11:02.056 --> 11:04.717
 They really wanted to end the war.
 
 11:05.398 --> 11:07.599
 The war had gone on for so long.
 
 11:07.979 --> 11:14.062
 It had been so costly and was in the eyes of the ministry and even the king not winnable.
 
 11:14.782 --> 11:27.008
 And so Sir Guy Compton found himself now in New York City, not as the commander-in-chief of the British Army in North America to subdue the rebels, but the man who was required now to negotiate the peace.
 
 11:28.369 --> 11:30.770
 And so Washington met with Sir Guy Compton,
 
 11:31.784 --> 11:35.606
 And they arranged what the withdrawal of British troops would be.
 
 11:36.626 --> 11:49.352
 On November 25th, 1783, Washington's army, of really what was left of it, passed at the edge of New York City and began their magnificent entry.
 
 11:49.812 --> 11:51.953
 In the meantime, the British were withdrawing.
 
 11:52.509 --> 11:56.353
 But, you know, the British were not terribly good losers.
 
 11:56.934 --> 12:00.438
 There was a flagpole down by Wall Street.
 
 12:00.778 --> 12:02.480
 They took down the Union Jack.
 
 12:02.981 --> 12:08.267
 And then so that the Americans would not be able to raise their flag, they greased the pole.
 
 12:09.665 --> 12:15.267
 And so as Washington and his army entered, he ordered, the general ordered the flag, the American flag be raised.
 
 12:15.687 --> 12:25.130
 And by some marvelous feature of clinging on to that pole, an American soldier managed to get to the top and to post the American colors.
 
 12:25.610 --> 12:26.451
 And the British left.
 
 12:26.871 --> 12:29.192
 New York City was now in American possession.
 
 12:29.632 --> 12:33.293
 And for all intents and purposes, now the war was over.
 
 12:34.639 --> 12:36.781
 Washington City for several days.
 
 12:37.501 --> 12:40.864
 And then it was his time to say farewell to his officers.
 
 12:42.225 --> 12:44.847
 And so he gathered them at Francis Tavern.
 
 12:45.168 --> 12:47.269
 Still there, by the way, and well seen.
 
 12:47.790 --> 12:51.073
 And there at Francis Tavern, he gathered his officers together.
 
 12:51.993 --> 12:57.178
 And with a moment of great emotion, he summoned each of them.
 
 12:58.078 --> 13:02.442
 And he took the hands of those officers who were present and bade them farewell.
 
 13:03.468 --> 13:11.012
 After the farewell at Francis Tavern, Washington then crossed the Hudson River to make another epic journey.
 
 13:11.492 --> 13:17.535
 This time he was going down to Annapolis in Maryland where the Congress was meeting.
 
 13:18.056 --> 13:25.239
 It was his turn to return the commission that had been given to him when he had taken command in 1775.
 
 13:27.697 --> 13:31.778
 He arrived in Annapolis, and again, the consummate actor.
 
 13:32.458 --> 13:42.780
 He presented himself to the Congress, and in this extraordinary moment, when you think about this, here was a general, a commander-in-chief who had won a revolution.
 
 13:43.140 --> 13:46.901
 He had been in the field with his army for eight years.
 
 13:47.221 --> 13:48.501
 The army loved him.
 
 13:48.861 --> 13:49.842
 And what was he doing?
 
 13:50.282 --> 13:56.063
 He was returning his commission that the Congress had given him as commander-in-chief.
 
 13:56.727 --> 14:04.270
 He was setting down the military laurels, literally gave them physically, gave the president of the Congress his commission.
 
 14:04.890 --> 14:07.432
 He then made a few remarks, not many.
 
 14:07.572 --> 14:09.893
 Washington was not one for long speeches.
 
 14:10.533 --> 14:15.275
 And then he returned home, and he returned home to Mount Vernon Christmas Eve 1783.
 
 14:15.315 --> 14:16.975
 After all those years, war was now over.
 
 14:24.005 --> 14:41.118
 Bill, you may be wanting to tell this story, and if you are, I apologize, but the story is that Benjamin West, the portrait artist, who was actually the king's portrait painter, and he was an American born in Pennsylvania, and the king said to him, what do you suppose Washington will do now that the war is over?
 
 14:41.198 --> 14:46.362
 Now, the king knew the only real force in the country was the Continental Army.
 
 14:46.423 --> 14:49.185
 Congress was pretty much powerless and ineffective.
 
 14:50.627 --> 14:55.895
 And think about it, at the end of a war like this, the conquering general would, we would assume, take power.
 
 14:56.375 --> 14:58.959
 But West said, I imagine he will go back to his farm.
 
 14:59.520 --> 15:03.867
 And the king said, if he does that, he will be the greatest man in the world.
 
 15:04.480 --> 15:26.310
 indeed indeed it may be apocryphal but it certainly summed up washington's extraordinary when you think about this he was a man who had been a military officer for a very long time it served in the french and indian war with great distinction and the american revolution obviously and he set down the sword he put down the sword and did in fact return to mount vernon
 
 15:27.571 --> 15:28.832
 It was his intention.
 
 15:28.852 --> 15:36.619
 I do believe we really can't get into George Washington's mind, but I do believe that he really did want to go back to being a farmer.
 
 15:36.739 --> 15:38.121
 He was a farmer.
 
 15:38.141 --> 15:39.041
 That's what he loved most.
 
 15:39.682 --> 15:46.628
 When you read Washington's writings, it comes through every time when he's talking about wheat and horses and all that sort of thing.
 
 15:46.909 --> 15:47.910
 He was very, very not.
 
 15:48.130 --> 15:49.651
 He was a scientific farmer.
 
 15:50.212 --> 15:51.433
 When he returned to Mount Vernon,
 
 15:52.542 --> 15:59.888
 1783, he took up correspondence with a number of Englishmen and French, for that matter, experimental and scientific farmers.
 
 16:00.469 --> 16:02.571
 He was a very fine farmer.
 
 16:03.271 --> 16:12.779
 Of course, as it turned out, the Republic was in crisis, understood that, and of course he returned to become president and save the Republic.
 
 16:12.799 --> 16:14.300
 There's no question of that.
 
 16:14.800 --> 16:19.064
 But he did it reluctantly, I think, and did it only because he realized and
 
 16:19.881 --> 16:21.864
 This was no amount of humility, by the way.
 
 16:21.964 --> 16:29.834
 Everyone realized that he was the only person who could lead the Republic, and he did, and did in great fashion.
 
 16:30.976 --> 16:57.036
 it's amazing we're talking with bill fowler professor emeritus at northeastern university and author of an american crisis george washington and the dangerous two years after yorktown talk about this extraordinary story about washington leading the continental army through the revolution and then turning his power back over to congress and going home as the republic continues to experience crisis crisis after crisis in the 1780s
 
 16:58.576 --> 17:10.561
 Early in the war, Bob, very early in the war, Billy Tudor, T-U-D-O-R, a Bostonian, he was the Adjutant General, served under Washington.
 
 17:11.061 --> 17:14.282
 And this was a time, 1776, when things weren't going so well.
 
 17:15.017 --> 17:17.057
 Washington was being driven out of New York City.
 
 17:17.537 --> 17:28.539
 But Billy Tudor wrote home to his wife, and I'd just like to quote what Billy Tudor said about Washington, because I think it sums up the way the men in the Continental Army felt about this general.
 
 17:29.160 --> 17:31.760
 Billy Tudor wrote to his wife.
 
 17:32.220 --> 17:41.982
 He said, and this, by the way, at a moment when the war was not going well, he wrote to his wife, quote, I cannot desert a man
 
 17:42.526 --> 17:57.199
 And it would certainly be desertion in a court of honor who has deserted everything to defend his country and whose chief misfortune among 10,000 others is that a large part of it wants spirit to defend itself.
 
 17:58.220 --> 18:01.063
 And I think that really some Washington was persistent.
 
 18:02.906 --> 18:04.947
 I don't know that he was a military genius.
 
 18:05.887 --> 18:08.087
 I made several military mistakes.
 
 18:08.547 --> 18:15.248
 But one of the things that characterized Washington was that his demeanor was the same in victory as in defeat.
 
 18:16.789 --> 18:25.590
 He exuded the same courage, personal, professional, physical courage, the same determination no matter whether he was winning or losing.
 
 18:26.390 --> 18:31.031
 That's what big people like Billy Treer saw in him, and they could not desert him.
 
 18:31.511 --> 18:31.711
 Right.
 
 18:31.872 --> 18:34.414
 And it also is what the officers at Newburgh saw.
 
 18:34.474 --> 18:42.463
 He says in that speech that he has been with them throughout the war, where Gates had not, and that he had been there.
 
 18:42.483 --> 18:46.768
 And there's a striking moment when he doesn't feel like he's quite convinced them.
 
 18:46.788 --> 18:47.448
 So he has a letter.
 
 18:48.289 --> 18:53.175
 Again, you tell this story in your book about the letter he pulls out and then puts on his glasses.
 
 18:54.436 --> 18:58.978
 He pulls out this letter, and the letter is from a congressman, Joseph Jones is his name.
 
 18:59.759 --> 19:01.980
 The letter itself is not terribly important.
 
 19:02.700 --> 19:07.623
 But as he begins to read the letter to these assembled group, he stumbles over the words.
 
 19:08.424 --> 19:15.088
 And as he stumbles over the words, again, the consummate active, he reaches into his pocket and he brings out a pair of glasses.
 
 19:15.428 --> 19:19.591
 Now, mind you, these glasses he had only received about two weeks before.
 
 19:19.631 --> 19:21.252
 He had never worn glasses before.
 
 19:22.152 --> 19:28.354
 And as he puts on these glasses, he says to the men in front of him, gentlemen, you must excuse me.
 
 19:28.714 --> 19:32.095
 My eyes have grown dim in the service of my country.
 
 19:32.756 --> 19:35.757
 Well, again, got a dry eye in the house.
 
 19:36.237 --> 19:39.278
 So Washington was the consummate leader.
 
 19:40.158 --> 19:42.659
 When we think about this, the war was eight years.
 
 19:42.679 --> 19:44.620
 He went home once.
 
 19:46.133 --> 19:49.195
 Eight years, he went home once.
 
 19:49.655 --> 19:54.779
 So he was in the field with his army all the time and frequently in the midst of the battle.
 
 19:55.419 --> 20:00.803
 He was a visible leader, a remarkable man, a very, very remarkable man.
 
 20:02.284 --> 20:03.785
 Where do you think this character came from?
 
 20:04.065 --> 20:07.647
 I mean, his real extraordinary character.
 
 20:10.409 --> 20:11.990
 That's a very good question.
 
 20:14.013 --> 20:15.274
 Washington was an aristocrat.
 
 20:15.554 --> 20:17.075
 Make no mistake about that.
 
 20:17.736 --> 20:19.938
 And he grew up in an aristocratic society.
 
 20:20.778 --> 20:34.289
 The 18th century aristocratic society, very much in Washington's world, a military society, was based upon certain fundamental elements, certain fundamental traits and virtues, bravery in combat, loyalty, discipline.
 
 20:34.349 --> 20:35.550
 He was a very disciplined man.
 
 20:36.530 --> 20:38.092
 He expected respect.
 
 20:38.152 --> 20:38.532
 Washington
 
 20:40.753 --> 20:52.844
 There's one anecdote told about Washington that when he was presiding at the Constitutional Convention, someone thought that Gouverneur Morris was a bit like Drake himself.
 
 20:53.224 --> 20:54.726
 Washington was always a very distant man.
 
 20:54.986 --> 20:59.750
 They said, I bet you don't dare go up and put your arm around General Washington.
 
 21:00.010 --> 21:03.233
 Well, Gouverneur Morris took the bet, put his arm around General Washington.
 
 21:03.273 --> 21:05.795
 Why did he give him a stare that would have frozen an iceberg?
 
 21:06.716 --> 21:14.043
 So Washington is a very aristocratic man, a man who devoted to honor responsibility as he viewed it.
 
 21:14.343 --> 21:19.167
 So I think that's what drove him forward was his sense and also a sense of dignity.
 
 21:20.328 --> 21:22.050
 He was he understood.
 
 21:22.070 --> 21:24.412
 It sounds so strange to say this.
 
 21:24.452 --> 21:31.739
 He really sort of understood his his place in history, like perhaps.
 
 21:32.728 --> 21:36.831
 I can think of other Americans who thought they understood their place in history.
 
 21:36.871 --> 21:38.231
 Washington truly did.
 
 21:38.572 --> 21:41.273
 And it was this dignity, this aloofness, again.
 
 21:41.894 --> 21:47.337
 I suspect if George Washington were to reappear in 2024, he probably could never be elected president.
 
 21:48.328 --> 21:49.149
 No, probably not.
 
 21:49.649 --> 21:50.369
 It wouldn't happen.
 
 21:50.389 --> 21:56.213
 I don't know if he would want, well, if he would want to be.
 
 21:56.714 --> 21:58.595
 He certainly wasn't one to suffer fools.
 
 21:59.015 --> 22:00.496
 No, that's very true.
 
 22:02.538 --> 22:06.520
 So a lot of us would be out of luck if he were trying to get close to Washington.
 
 22:06.580 --> 22:08.942
 We would be dismissed from his presence, I'm sure.
 
 22:08.962 --> 22:11.183
 Almost immediately, yes.
 
 22:11.624 --> 22:17.127
 So he doesn't suffer fools, but then he does manage to attract coterie, a very able people.
 
 22:17.207 --> 22:17.387
 Oh, yes.
 
 22:18.349 --> 22:20.500
 Hamilton, Henry Knox, Nathaniel Green.
 
 22:23.621 --> 22:27.343
 You know, it's an interesting collection of talent because they all don't get along, obviously.
 
 22:27.403 --> 22:30.444
 I mean, Jefferson and Hamilton certainly didn't get along.
 
 22:30.945 --> 22:32.185
 But he had this capacity.
 
 22:32.425 --> 22:35.087
 I think that people wanted to serve with him.
 
 22:36.287 --> 22:37.408
 I don't know serving under him.
 
 22:37.448 --> 22:38.889
 I think that's a bit of an exaggeration.
 
 22:39.129 --> 22:42.270
 But it was a distinct pleasure and a privilege to serve with him.
 
 22:42.791 --> 22:49.794
 By the way, when you read the letters of these men, Jefferson, Knox, Hamilton, all of these men, they always treat him with the greatest of respect.
 
 22:50.515 --> 22:53.116
 Rarely do you find – you can find it, but rarely do you find –
 
 22:53.456 --> 22:58.457
 Any disparaging remarks, they all held him in very high regard.
 
 22:58.917 --> 23:02.078
 He was above all of them, I think, and he understood that.
 
 23:02.398 --> 23:05.719
 He understood that somehow he was on a level above them.
 
 23:06.779 --> 23:13.461
 Now are there any who feel that he is overblown or that I should be on this other than say Horatio Gates?
 
 23:13.501 --> 23:15.622
 I know John Adams is jealous of most people.
 
 23:16.840 --> 23:23.342
 Well, you know, we've had over 200 years to search the character of this man, to read his letters, to read other letters, etc.
 
 23:23.382 --> 23:27.863
 And I don't think there's any person in American history who's been examined more closely.
 
 23:28.003 --> 23:28.743
 And guess what?
 
 23:29.524 --> 23:30.644
 He comes out pretty good.
 
 23:30.664 --> 23:33.665
 I mean, he has his flaws, but
 
 23:34.739 --> 23:58.668
 you know unlike certain other figures in american history who have somewhat shady characters shall we say washington never did he was as he appeared to be now he has his faults again he wasn't necessarily military he had a temper by the way yeah he had a ferocious temper but no we've examined him everybody you know turned over every leaf every page of his writings and he always comes out pretty good
 
 24:00.953 --> 24:01.674
 That's interesting.
 
 24:03.095 --> 24:05.877
 Now, of course, Billy Lee is with him through the war.
 
 24:06.117 --> 24:08.939
 Yes, yes, yes.
 
 24:09.599 --> 24:12.181
 Billy Lee was his servant, his slave, to be sure.
 
 24:12.582 --> 24:13.382
 Washington had slaves.
 
 24:13.402 --> 24:14.063
 There's no question.
 
 24:14.083 --> 24:15.644
 He was a typical southern planter.
 
 24:15.964 --> 24:19.727
 But Billy Lee was with him almost from day one to the end of the war.
 
 24:20.720 --> 24:23.522
 After the war, Billy Lee is incapacitated.
 
 24:23.542 --> 24:29.067
 I don't know what the proper description would be, but he was somewhat immobile.
 
 24:29.267 --> 24:33.751
 But Washington brought him, and he was in company with Washington all of the time.
 
 24:34.671 --> 24:37.213
 Washington had an interesting attitude towards slavery.
 
 24:37.494 --> 24:38.895
 Not that he was a modern man.
 
 24:39.475 --> 24:40.556
 He was a slave owner.
 
 24:40.596 --> 24:41.637
 There's no question about that.
 
 24:42.449 --> 24:44.930
 But in his will, he freed his slaves.
 
 24:45.750 --> 24:46.631
 He could not free.
 
 24:46.671 --> 24:48.412
 He also owned many slaves.
 
 24:48.452 --> 24:50.332
 Well, they actually owned Martha, his wife.
 
 24:50.773 --> 24:51.833
 And he couldn't free those.
 
 24:52.153 --> 24:54.594
 But the slaves that he owned, he did free.
 
 24:56.750 --> 25:01.714
 Washington had deep misgivings about slavery, and I think from many points of view.
 
 25:02.215 --> 25:07.099
 I mentioned that he was a very fine farmer, and he was, and he saw slavery as inefficient.
 
 25:07.539 --> 25:14.225
 He saw it as a poor way to farm because the slaves had no incentive to do better.
 
 25:15.726 --> 25:18.007
 He was very interested in modern methods of agriculture.
 
 25:18.047 --> 25:25.212
 He found it hard to implement them because what incentive was there for the workers, for the slaves in this plantation to do that?
 
 25:25.653 --> 25:30.416
 And also, I think he had moral questions about it, too, as did many Southerners.
 
 25:30.456 --> 25:32.277
 But nonetheless, he was a slave owner.
 
 25:32.297 --> 25:33.398
 There's no question about that.
 
 25:34.579 --> 25:42.084
 Now, how does he translate his military capability into then being president?
 
 25:42.144 --> 25:42.765
 I mean, what's the...
 
 25:43.442 --> 25:44.303
 What's the trajectory there?
 
 25:44.363 --> 25:47.648
 What's the learning curve for becoming a politician?
 
 25:47.668 --> 25:48.890
 Or have you always been a politician?
 
 25:48.950 --> 25:51.874
 Is that intrinsic to being a successful general, being a good politician?
 
 25:51.894 --> 25:53.096
 I think he'd always been a politician.
 
 25:53.116 --> 25:54.798
 Remember, he did serve in the House of Burgesses.
 
 25:54.878 --> 25:55.660
 That's true, yeah.
 
 25:56.220 --> 25:59.405
 I think Washington was the best connected man in America.
 
 25:59.986 --> 26:01.887
 He had eight years as commander in chief.
 
 26:02.387 --> 26:06.228
 He knew everyone who was important in every state.
 
 26:06.268 --> 26:09.769
 There was no other person in the nation who was as well known.
 
 26:10.089 --> 26:13.250
 So Washington had a very intricate network of contacts.
 
 26:13.710 --> 26:16.551
 He was in touch with many, many people who were in touch with him.
 
 26:17.051 --> 26:19.692
 He knew he had his fingers on the pulse of the nation.
 
 26:20.392 --> 26:24.513
 He knew what was going on in Massachusetts, Virginia, South Carolina, Georgia.
 
 26:25.013 --> 26:27.474
 No one was better informed and better educated.
 
 26:28.280 --> 26:35.963
 And so he was at this, Mount Vernon is kind of a nexus of political activities, an intelligence center in the period after the war.
 
 26:36.263 --> 26:37.304
 So he knows what's going on.
 
 26:37.584 --> 26:38.324
 And he's very clever.
 
 26:38.624 --> 26:42.606
 He knows he is an astute politician, no question about that.
 
 26:43.006 --> 26:50.649
 So he's able to maneuver this thing and staying above the fray to be sure he knew what was going on in the fray.
 
 26:50.949 --> 26:51.129
 Right.
 
 26:56.511 --> 26:57.031
 Interesting.
 
 26:57.812 --> 27:09.197
 We've been talking with Bill Fowler, Professor Emeritus of History at Northeastern University, author of An American Crisis, George Washington and the Dangerous Three Years After Yorktown.
 
 27:09.217 --> 27:10.637
 I want to thank you for joining us, Bill.
 
 27:10.657 --> 27:12.718
 I think we just lost our connection with Bill.
 
 27:14.499 --> 27:15.059
 We're still there.
 
 27:15.579 --> 27:16.380
 I'm still here, Bob.
 
 27:16.420 --> 27:16.740
 Thank you.
 
 27:18.641 --> 27:20.081
 Bob, I want to thank you, too.
 
 27:20.141 --> 27:24.984
 And I want to thank you and all of your associates are doing so much as we get close to the 250th anniversary.
 
 27:26.499 --> 27:29.340
 It's an anniversary that we ought to celebrate and understand very well.
 
 27:29.360 --> 27:30.941
 So thank you for all the work that you're doing.
 
 27:31.281 --> 27:32.262
 Well, thank you for joining us.
 
 27:32.342 --> 27:39.545
 And I want to thank Jonathan Lane, who is our operator for Revolution 250, as we're trying to get all of these things underway.
 
 27:39.625 --> 27:41.286
 And I want to thank our listeners.
 
 27:41.306 --> 27:45.808
 You know, the last time you spoke to us, Bill, we imagined we'd have a small listenership, but it's actually grown.
 
 27:45.868 --> 27:47.089
 And so every week I...
 
 27:47.569 --> 27:50.853
 Every week, I thank people in various parts of the world who are tuning in.
 
 27:50.873 --> 28:00.003
 And if you're interested in one of our lapel pins or refrigerator magnets, send an email to Jonathan Lane, jlane at revolution250.org.
 
 28:00.704 --> 28:02.226
 And this week, if you are in...
 
 28:02.646 --> 28:24.109
 cragero norway or north las vegas nevada needham massachusetts coatesville pennsylvania melbourne australia montreal or galway uh let us hear from you and i thank you for joining us and thanks to all folks between and beyond these points and now uh doug quigley and dave and peter emmerich will pipe us out on the road to boston